ResearchClimate ResilienceResilient Design Strategies

Site-scale strategies for heat, stormwater and drought

Published evidence for shade trees, bioretention, mulch and turf replacement, where it is thin or fails, and the rules that govern them in California.

Field Method · AI-assisted research roundupPublished Sources checked

Heat, flood, stormwater and drought each have a landscape response with some published performance data. Heat studies measure temperatures at a place. Stormwater studies measure runoff and pollutants from a device. Drought evidence is mostly irrigation records and regulation. Flood evidence at the site scale is thin in the sources we could open, so the flood section covers the rules that apply. The useful question for a design is what a source measured, in which climate, at what scale, and under what maintenance.

This article sets out what each source says, as read on November 14, 2026, and labels our interpretation. It is not legal, engineering or safety advice. Stormwater, flood and water-efficiency rules vary by agency and edition, and every regulatory passage below needs review by a licensed professional and the local agency. For screening a site for these hazards before choosing strategies, see Climate risk screening tools for site design.

Heat: shade works, and the number depends on what you measure

The EPA’s heat island compendium chapter on trees and vegetation is a 2008 draft. It reports that generally 10 to 30 percent of summer sun reaches the ground below a tree, and cites maximum surface temperature reductions of 20 to 45°F (11 to 25°C) on walls and roofs at two buildings. Measured air differences include peak temperatures in tree groves 9°F (5°C) cooler than over open terrain, and suburbs with mature trees 4 to 6°F (2 to 3°C) cooler than new suburbs without trees. Added vegetation can increase water demand. EPA, Trees and Vegetation

A New Haven, Connecticut field study made 156 bicycle sensor rides from 2019 to 2021. Cooling was the difference from a reference station, with canopy estimated within 90 m of each reading. On clear days, canopy was associated with air 1.62°C cooler at midday, 1.19°C in the afternoon and 1.15°C in the morning. On cloudy days the association fell to 0.92°C in the morning and 0.51°C in the afternoon. On the hottest days it was 1.78°C on clear afternoons, but 1.12°C at clear midday and 1.17°C at cloudy midday, below the all-days clear midday value. The abstract gives no value per unit of canopy cover. Locke et al. 2024

A 2025 review of 115 studies from 2018 to 2024 finds that trees generally cool better than other vegetation, especially in hotter, drier climates where water is available. Land surface and air temperature respond differently to canopy, which produces conflicting conclusions, and arid zones are underrepresented. Named gaps include native versus non-native species in arid climates, urban form, and tree performance in extreme heat. Most studies are small. Alonzo et al. 2025

Our reading: shade is well supported for lowering surface temperatures under the canopy. The air temperature association at pedestrian height is smaller, a degree or two Celsius in New Haven, and varies with sun and time of day. Nothing we read measured shade trees in San Diego County.

Paving. The EPA’s cool pavements chapter is a 2012 draft. It cites Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory estimates that each 10 percent increase in solar reflectance could lower surface temperatures by 7°F (4°C), and that raising citywide pavement reflectance from 10 to 35 percent could lower air temperature by about 1°F (0.6°C). It says few studies have measured pavements’ role in heat islands. Permeable pavements can cool by evaporation when wet. When dry, their surface may be hotter than an impermeable equivalent, though preliminary research shows the subsurface is generally similar or cooler. EPA, Cool Pavements Our reading: in dry-summer areas such as much of San Diego County, expect the dry case in the heat season, so drainage and coolness can pull against each other.

Stormwater: field evidence for biofiltration and pooled BMPs

The EPA describes bioretention as sunken areas where runoff ponds before it soaks in or leaves through an underdrain, and lists infiltration as a function only where there is no underdrain. Permeable pavement stores water below and infiltrates it or sends it to an underdrain. EPA, Types of Green Infrastructure In the City of San Diego’s manual, biofiltration with partial retention has a stone infiltration storage zone below the underdrain outlet and manages runoff through infiltration, evapotranspiration and biofiltration. City of San Diego, Stormwater Standards Our reading: a lined, underdrained cell works as a filter and detention device, while an unlined cell with a raised outlet still infiltrates part of the volume. State the intended function in the design.

A screening tool. The EPA’s National Stormwater Calculator (version 3.4.0, August 10, 2022) uses SWMM to estimate annual runoff and runoff frequency for seven controls, including rain gardens, green roofs, infiltration basins and porous pavement. The page describes it for sites under 12 acres and for screening small sites with uniform soils. It cannot model treatment trains or take user weather data. EPA, National Stormwater Calculator It compares options and does not replace the local sizing method.

Field results for biofiltration. A field study of three biofiltration systems in two climates found peak runoff rates reduced by at least 80 percent, for small to medium storms. Hatt, Fletcher and Deletic 2009 A 2008 presentation by the authors’ research group names two of the systems, at the Monash University car park and at Saturn Crescent, and gives a 33 percent average runoff volume reduction for the Monash system, which was lined and undersized. FAWB, Performance We did not read the full paper.

Pollutants. A 2024 meta-analysis of US field studies pooled several best management practice types, so its figures are not specific to bioretention. Mean concentration reductions were 80.9 percent for suspended sediment, 57.4 percent for fecal indicator bacteria, 34.0 percent for total nitrogen and 32.7 percent for total phosphorus. Dissolved inorganic nitrogen and orthophosphate showed no clear change. Studies clustered in the mid-Atlantic, arid regions were underrepresented, the median study lasted 2 to 3 years, and 59 percent of 222 effect sizes lacked standard deviations. Schramm et al. 2024 Our reading: concentrations leave out the volume lost to infiltration and evapotranspiration, which drives load. Neither source gave results for a winter-rain, dry-summer climate, and for San Diego the nutrient numbers are the weakest evidence we found. No permeable pavement field study was opened, so we give no performance figures for it.

Where it fails. An undated EPA review of 22 green infrastructure projects funded under the 2009 Recovery Act, with data to the end of 2010, says failure to maintain can lead to excessive sedimentation, clogged inlets and outlets, loss of plantings, soil compaction and failure to infiltrate. Fifty-five percent of the projects had an O&M plan or manual and 27 percent a tracking system. EPA, O&M report Our reading: maintenance belongs in the design. In that sample, 45 percent had no plan.

Stormwater authority in California and San Diego

Stormwater discharges in California are regulated through NPDES permits. The program is run by the Water Boards, which are the State Water Resources Control Board and nine Regional Boards, and covers municipal separate storm sewer systems, construction and industrial activity. State Water Board

The regional municipal permit is Order No. R9-2013-0001, as amended by Order Nos. R9-2015-0001 and R9-2015-0100. The San Diego Water Board says it expired June 27, 2018 but “remains in effect under an administrative extension” until reissued, and that the Board has begun developing changes. San Diego Water Board The County’s 2020 BMP Design Manual gives guidance for complying with that order and lists January 2025 revisions. The County Watershed Protection Ordinance defines the legally enforceable requirements in the unincorporated area. County of San Diego

The City of San Diego updated its Stormwater Standards effective August 15, 2024. The changes include BMPs in floodplains and floodways, maintenance responsibility, the design capture volume worksheet and biofiltration requirements. City of San Diego, update notice The figures below are from the August 2024 edition. City of San Diego, Stormwater Standards

  • Priority development project thresholds include new development creating 10,000 square feet or more of impervious surfaces; redevelopment creating or replacing 5,000 square feet or more of impervious surface on an existing site of 10,000 square feet or more of impervious surfaces; 5,000 square feet or more for restaurants, hillside development on natural slopes of 25 percent or more, parking lots, and streets, roads and driveways; and 2,500 square feet or more where the project discharges directly to an Environmentally Sensitive Area. Other categories apply.
  • The design capture volume is the runoff from the 24-hour, 85th percentile storm.
  • Projects are sorted into full, partial or no infiltration conditions, which point to infiltration, partial retention or biofiltration BMPs.
  • Landscape architect tasks listed: select plants and prepare planting plans for vegetated stormwater features, write planting, establishment and maintenance specifications, and help develop irrigation plans that limit non-stormwater runoff.
  • Trees as site design BMPs earn up to 0.25 of the design capture volume in total and 400 cubic feet per tree. Larger credit requires designing the tree as a pollutant control BMP, infiltration feasibility screening and City Engineer approval.
  • BMPs in a 100-year floodplain or floodway must show they still meet the manual’s performance standards during floods, comply with the City’s floodplain management requirements, and go to City Floodplain Management for review.

Confirm the current edition and the reviewing jurisdiction (City, County or other) before a submittal.

Drought: California’s landscape rules and the evidence behind them

California’s Model Water Efficient Landscape Ordinance (MWELO) is in Title 23 of the California Code of Regulations. The Department of Water Resources says the current text took effect January 2, 2025, that every local agency must adopt it or a local ordinance at least as effective, and that local ordinances are usually more stringent. DWR, MWELO

The ordinance applies to new construction with a landscape area of 500 square feet or more that needs a building or landscape permit, plan check or design review, and to rehabilitated landscapes of 2,500 square feet or more. Registered historical sites and ecological restoration without a permanent irrigation system are among the exceptions. 23 CCR § 491

New construction with a landscape area between 500 and 2,500 square feet may use the prescriptive option instead of the performance option. If chosen, its requirements are mandatory. They include:

  • compost at least four cubic yards per 1,000 square feet, to a depth of six inches, unless a soil test contraindicates it; soils with more than 6 percent organic matter in the top six inches are exempt;
  • plants with an average WUCOLS plant factor of 0.3 on 75 percent of a residential landscape and 100 percent of a non-residential one, excluding edible-plant areas and areas using recycled water;
  • turfgrass of no more than 25 percent of a residential landscape area, and none in non-residential landscapes;
  • no turfgrass on slopes steeper than one foot of rise in four feet of run;
  • a minimum three-inch mulch layer on exposed soil in planting areas, with stated exceptions. 23 CCR § 492

The performance option’s documentation package includes a soil management report, landscape design, grading design and irrigation design plans, and a water efficient landscape worksheet. 23 CCR § 491.4 Local agencies must prevent water waste from inefficient irrigation and set penalties locally. The same section refers projects in Very High Fire Hazard Severity Zones and State Responsibility Areas to the California Fire Code and local fuel modification rules. 23 CCR § 490.1 This article does not cover fire safety. Ask the local fire authority what applies to mulch and plants near buildings. Check the adopted local ordinance. We did not open the WUCOLS list or the water budget formula.

What the evidence says. We did not find a primary study of mulch performance that we could open and read for this article, so we report no figures for evaporation or soil temperature. The three-inch minimum above is the regulation’s requirement, not a performance finding.

SCCWRP and the County of San Diego are running a two-year study in three inland residential communities, measuring how irrigation water and rainfall infiltrate or run off from turf, drip-irrigated landscape and impermeable surfaces. It moved into field data collection in September, per a post dated October 31, 2025, and reports no new results. It cites an earlier SCCWRP study finding that turf replacement can eliminate dry-weather irrigation runoff, and all rainfall runoff in 85 percent of storms. SCCWRP We found no measured landscape water-use reduction we could cite. Because tree cooling depends on available water (Alonzo, above), a drought-tolerant palette and a shade goal can conflict.

Flood: design rainfall and floodplain rules

We found no primary site-scale study of how a landscape strategy changes flood damage. The sources give the design rainfall and the legal frame. Reading flood maps and precipitation data for a site is covered in Climate risk screening tools for site design.

NOAA’s current precipitation frequency estimates are NOAA Atlas 14; California is Volume 6, from 2011. NOAA’s May 2026 progress report calls Atlas 15 the future national standard and anticipated preliminary contiguous-US estimates by September 2026. NOAA HDSC, May 2026 As read on November 14, 2026, the undated Atlas 15 page still calls Atlas 14 the existing national standard and shows only the Montana pilot, released September 26, 2024. The page’s timeline gives preliminary contiguous-US estimates no earlier than September 2026 and publication no earlier than September 2027, while other text on the page says 2026 for both. NOAA, Atlas 15 We found no NOAA announcement that the preliminary estimates had been released. Ask the reviewing agency which atlas applies.

FEMA defines base flood elevation as the water surface level on a flood insurance rate map for a flood with a 1 percent chance in any year. FEMA, Base Flood Elevation Federal rules define development as “any man-made change to improved or unimproved real estate”, and the definition includes filling, grading and paving. 44 CFR § 59.1 Communities must require permits for development in flood-prone areas. Where base flood elevations exist, new residential lowest floors generally must be at or above the base flood level. In an adopted regulatory floodway, encroachments including fill are prohibited unless hydrologic and hydraulic analyses show no increase in flood levels during the base flood. Where no floodway is designated in Zones A1-30 and AE, development including fill, combined with other development, must not raise the base flood elevation more than one foot. 44 CFR § 60.3

So regrading, raised planters and berms in a mapped floodplain fall under the community’s floodplain permit, and fill in a floodway needs a hydraulic analysis by a qualified engineer. The community holds that authority within FEMA’s minimum criteria and any stricter state or local rule. Ask the local floodplain administrator early.

How to compare strategies and record their limits

These steps are our suggestion, built from the gaps above. No source requires them.

  1. Record the hazard and the metric. Surface temperature, air temperature, runoff volume and pollutant concentration are different measurements. Name which one the strategy is meant to change.
  2. Record the source and its setting. Note the climate, scale, number of sites and years of data. A mid-Atlantic nutrient result is not a San Diego value. Record the site’s own hazard reading as the screening article describes.
  3. Record the failure mode. For a cell, clogging, compaction and lost plantings. For shade, water supply. For paving, a drainage benefit that costs surface heat.
  4. Record who maintains it, and how. The EPA review shows many projects in its sample lacked a plan.
  5. Record the authority. Name the agency, the permit and the edition of the manual or code used.
  6. Record what is unknown. An unmeasured value is better stated as unknown than borrowed from another climate.

Open questions

  • What do San Diego County field measurements show for shade trees, bioretention and turf replacement, once the SCCWRP study reports?
  • How do vegetated BMPs establish and perform through San Diego’s dry season, and what irrigation do they need?
  • What field data exist for permeable pavement hydrology and surface heat in a dry-summer climate?
  • When will the San Diego Water Board reissue the regional permit, and what will change for priority development projects?
  • What is the evidence for planting strategies as flood protection at the site scale?

Using this in Field Method

Site Dossier gathers public layers for a point in San Diego County, among them terrain, sun, soils, water and native planting zones. Those layers help you ask which of the strategies above a site could host. They do not test a strategy, size a BMP or establish an infiltration condition. A geotechnical investigation and the local manual do that.

Sources

  1. US EPA — Reducing Urban Heat Islands: Compendium of Strategies, Trees and Vegetation (draft, 2008)
  2. Locke et al. (2024) — Variation in the relationship between urban tree canopy and air temperature reduction under a range of daily weather conditions
  3. Alonzo, Ibsen and Locke (2025) — Urban trees and cooling: a review of the recent literature (2018 to 2024)
  4. US EPA — Reducing Urban Heat Islands: Compendium of Strategies, Cool Pavements (draft, 2012)
  5. US EPA — Types of Green Infrastructure
  6. City of San Diego — Stormwater Standards, BMP Design Manual (August 2024 edition)
  7. US EPA — National Stormwater Calculator
  8. Hatt, Fletcher and Deletic (2009) — Hydrologic and pollutant removal performance of stormwater biofiltration systems at the field scale
  9. Facility for Advancing Water Biofiltration (Monash University) — Performance presentation (2008)
  10. Schramm et al. (2024) — A meta-analysis of the impacts of best management practices on nonpoint source pollutant concentration
  11. US EPA — A Review of Green Infrastructure O&M Practices in ARRA Clean Water State Revolving Fund Projects
  12. California State Water Resources Control Board — Storm Water Program
  13. San Diego Regional Water Quality Control Board — San Diego Municipal Storm Water Permit
  14. County of San Diego — Best Management Practice Design Manual
  15. City of San Diego — Stormwater Standards Manual Minor Update, public notice (July 15, 2024)
  16. California Department of Water Resources — Model Water Efficient Landscape Ordinance
  17. Cal. Code Regs. tit. 23, § 491 — Applicability
  18. Cal. Code Regs. tit. 23, § 492 — Prescriptive Compliance Option
  19. Cal. Code Regs. tit. 23, § 491.4 — Elements of the Landscape Documentation Package
  20. Cal. Code Regs. tit. 23, § 490.1 — General Provisions
  21. SCCWRP — Turf replacement study quantifying water-quality benefits of drip-irrigated landscapes
  22. NOAA National Weather Service — Hydrometeorological Design Studies Center Progress Report (May 2026)
  23. NOAA Office of Water Prediction — Atlas 15 information page
  24. FEMA — Base Flood Elevation
  25. 44 CFR § 59.1 — Definitions (eCFR)
  26. 44 CFR § 60.3 — Flood plain management criteria for flood-prone areas (eCFR)

These tools support site review and design studies. Read each tool’s stated capabilities and limits before use.

Explore Site Dossier
Back to Research