ResearchCodes and ComplianceCode Compliance Strategies

Code compliance checks by design phase

How GSA, Caltrans, California's DSA and San Diego agencies stage their reviews, what each stage asks to be confirmed, and a phase checkpoint record of our own.

Field Method · AI-assisted research roundupPublished Sources checked

Our premise, which we could not test, is that a compliance problem usually costs less to fix the earlier it is found. We found no published evidence for this on landscape projects. Public owners and plan-check agencies do divide their own reviews into stages, and they publish what each stage is for. Our suggestion is that a practice borrow that structure: place a check at the end of each design phase, tie it to what the reviewing agency will ask at its next stage, and keep a dated record of what was checked against which edition.

This article describes what five public bodies publish about their stages, as read on November 15, 2026, and where to read each one. It does not restate technical requirements. Each procedure applies to that body’s own projects, and none of this is legal or engineering advice.

Two earlier articles cover neighbouring ground and are not repeated here. Finding adopted codes for California landscape projects covers which code edition applies. Landscape permit submittals and project records covers what a submittal and a resubmittal contain.

A federal owner: GSA’s Core Building Standards and submittal matrix

Until 2025 the General Services Administration (GSA) set design standards for its buildings in a document called P100. GSA’s page now says P100 “established” those standards, in the past tense, and leads with the Public Buildings Service (PBS) Core Building Standards. The 2024 P100 files are still posted lower on the same page. GSA, Core Building Standards page

A GSA memorandum of February 24, 2025 states that P100 “is no longer applicable and is rescinded”, unless the memorandum or the PBS Commissioner permits otherwise in writing. The same memorandum issued interim Core Building Standards. GSA, memorandum of February 24, 2025 Readers who know P100 should treat it as superseded.

The current edition is the 2026 PBS Core Building Standards, issued by memorandum on September 21, 2026. The memorandum says it applies to PBS projects, such as contracts for design, construction, services or studies, awarded on or after October 1, 2026 in GSA-owned or lease-construction facilities. GSA contracting officers shall incorporate the standards into those contracts. Active projects awarded under earlier standards should implement the 2026 edition to the greatest extent practicable. GSA, 2026 Core Building Standards

The standard is a list. It names laws, executive orders, codes, regulations and standards by discipline, and Section 2 covers community planning and landscape design. GSA describes the list as for reference only and does not warrant it as complete. It says compliance is the responsibility of the contractor and its subcontractors, and that project teams must use the latest published edition of each listed authority in effect on the project’s solicitation date, except where the standard says otherwise. GSA, 2026 Core Building Standards

The memorandum names a submittal matrix among its resource documents, as the document that sets baseline submittal requirements. The matrix we found posted on GSA’s page is titled 2025 Interim Core Building Standards Submittal Matrix, Version 1.0. We did not find one labelled 2026. It covers four delivery methods: design-bid-build, design-build, design-build-bridging and construction manager as constructor. It says it identifies the items GSA requires to validate that a project is moving forward while meeting the Core Building Standards. Project teams must still provide the standard of care for a fully constructible set of documents, and the project contract may add requirements. GSA, Core Building Standards Submittal Matrix

For design-bid-build, the matrix names these deliverable phases: preliminary concept, concept development, final concept, design development at 100 percent, and construction documents at 65 percent, 95 percent and final. Each phase is marked with the funding codes it applies to. Within a phase, pages are grouped by discipline, and one group is community and landscape. Each page lists subject headings, keyed to a section of the standards, with the items due at that phase. At preliminary concept, the community and landscape headings include zoning analysis, site and landscape strategy, natural features and stormwater management; landscape irrigation is listed but marked N/A at that phase. A general heading for code and safety asks for a list of applicable codes at preliminary concept and for a signed and sealed certification statement at final construction documents. GSA, Core Building Standards Submittal Matrix We read the opening pages and a sample of later ones. Read the published file for the items at each phase.

What we take from it: an owner that names its phases also names what it expects to see at each one. On a GSA project, read the contract first; the matrix sets the baseline deliverables for each phase. On other projects the matrix is an example of form only.

A state transportation owner: Caltrans

Caltrans organises project development around numbered milestones. Chapter 8 of its Project Development Procedures Manual gives an overview and refers readers to a separate workflow tasks manual for the individual tasks. The design milestones run as follows. Caltrans PDPM, Chapter 8

  • Milestones 200 to 260, initiate project design. Once the preferred alternative is chosen and the project approved, preparation of plans, specifications and estimate (PS&E) can begin.
  • Milestones 260 to 300, detailed design. Functional units develop details, quantities and specifications. The consolidated plans are then circulated for review and comment in the district.
  • Milestones 300 to 380, complete design. District comments are considered, a safety review is conducted, and the PS&E are completed. The manual says an environmental reevaluation should be conducted to confirm that the design is within the framework of the project approval document.

The same chapter says on-site field reviews for project development, safety analysis, constructability review and safety review may be held at the same time on some projects. Each must be documented separately by the responsible functional units.

Chapter 29 applies the process to highway planting. Following project report approval, the project landscape architect should prepare the preliminary design. At 60 percent completion of that design, a review by the district landscape architect should be requested. The district landscape architect must ensure that the project complies with Caltrans’ policies and standards in Chapter 900 of the Highway Design Manual. As portions of the project enter the PS&E package, the package should be reviewed for consistency and conformity with the entire submittal. The district landscape architect should also verify that the design intent statement stays current and consistent with the PS&E. Caltrans PDPM, Chapter 29

Chapter 29 is dated May 24, 2018 and Chapter 8 November 6, 2024. We did not read the Highway Design Manual, the workflow tasks manual or the Landscape Architecture PS&E Guide that Chapter 29 names. These are Caltrans procedures for State highway projects.

A state plan-check agency: the Division of the State Architect

The Division of the State Architect (DSA) reviews plans for the projects submitted to it. The procedures we read refer to school district project teams and to school and community college projects. We did not read which projects need DSA approval. Its back check procedure sets out four stages for obtaining approval. DSA, PR 24-01

  1. Project registration. Projects are required to be registered six to eight weeks before the submittal date.
  2. Intake. DSA performs a readiness check. A project that is not “complete, coordinated and construction ready” is sent back as incomplete.
  3. Plan review. The project is reviewed for compliance with the structural safety, access compliance, and fire and life safety portions of the California Building Code. Some projects are also reviewed for energy and green building standards.
  4. Back check. After the design team has addressed every comment, DSA rechecks, generally in two phases: a desk back check that DSA conducts independently, then an in-person back check if the plans are still incomplete or not code compliant.

Two details bear on in-house checking. The lead design professional requests a back check appointment only when each DSA correction comment has a detailed reply explaining how the design team resolved it and where the solution is located. DSA, PR 24-01 Within a week of registration, DSA notifies the applicant to upload progress drawings. The applicant shall then upload the most current drawings for all disciplines, so DSA can understand scope and schedule staff. DSA, PR 17-03

DSA’s submittal checklist states the bar for stage 2. Projects must include construction documents that are one-hundred percent complete, coordinated across all disciplines and ready for construction. The checklist is to be completed by the design professional responsible for quality control and coordination review, and DSA recommends reviewing it when the project is registered. It lists a code analysis among the documents. It also lists a form for outdoor water use self-certification of landscape irrigation design, required as applicable on school and community college projects. DSA 3, Project Submittal Checklist

What we take from it: DSA’s readiness check is a published definition of ready to submit. Ask DSA which projects and landscape scopes need its approval.

A city: San Diego’s steps before and at submittal

The City of San Diego’s guide to its submittal process lists steps to take before design: determine the zoning, the allowed uses and the regulations on size and scale, identify other development regulations, determine whether the property contains environmentally sensitive lands or historical resources, consider geologic hazards, identify code requirements, and determine the type of permit or approval. It says that evaluating parcel information before designing can avoid early mistakes, save time and reduce processing costs. It also notes that outside agencies may require their own permits. San Diego Land Development Manual, Section 1

The City offers an early check of its own. Preliminary Review is a voluntary service before formal submittal. The applicant submits a questionnaire of up to ten specific questions with supporting documents, and staff give a written response. The bulletin says the service is not a plan check and is not intended to replace services provided by design professionals. The information expires one year from the date the application is deemed complete. It may expire sooner if a code the responses rely on changes, the City Council enacts emergency legislation or the project scope changes. San Diego Information Bulletin 513

For development permits and approvals, all submitted projects are evaluated to ensure that the information required for review is provided. The City calls this the completeness review, and the section’s minimum submittal requirements checklist describes the required content. The section also describes professional certification as one way to accomplish the review; read it for who is eligible. San Diego Land Development Manual, Section 4

A county: San Diego County’s building permit steps

The County’s guide How to Obtain a Building Permit (form PDS 441A, revised October 26, 2026) sets out the process in numbered steps and describes itself as a guide only. Before plans are prepared, it asks the applicant to consult Environmental Health, Zoning, Fire and Land Development for requirements that may affect the project. Before submittal, plans go to the Building Plan Pre-Submittal Review counter for approvals from Zoning, Building, Land Development and Environmental Health. The documents received at submittal include the conditions of approval, all of which must be completed before the permit is issued. County staff review the plans for compliance with codes and ordinances, and County specialties issue correction lists. The applicant answers each list with a response list describing where and how every item was addressed, and the recheck repeats until all corrections are approved. Before issuance the applicant submits evidence that the conditions of approval have been satisfied. County of San Diego, PDS 441A The guide also gives fees and processing times that we do not repeat. The County’s forms and staff define what each stage requires.

What the stages have in common

This section is our interpretation of the five sources.

  • Plan-check agencies separate “is it complete?” from “does it comply?” DSA’s intake and the City’s completeness review come before substantive review. The County’s guide places a pre-submittal review by Zoning, Building, Land Development and Environmental Health ahead of submittal.
  • Several ask for evidence at a named point. GSA’s matrix, Caltrans’ 60 percent review and DSA’s checklist each fix a moment and a deliverable.
  • Some require a record. DSA requires a detailed reply to every correction comment before back check. Caltrans requires each concurrent field review to be documented separately. The County asks for a response list showing where and how each correction was addressed.
  • The early stages are about applicability. The City’s steps and its preliminary review ask which rules and permits apply before asking whether a drawing meets them. GSA’s matrix asks for a list of applicable codes at preliminary concept.
  • Editions are pinned to a date. GSA ties the listed authorities to the solicitation date. The City’s preliminary review answers expire.

A phase checkpoint record

The table below is our method, built from the pattern above. It is untested, and it does not replace any agency’s checklist. The rows describe checks on the practice’s own sheets and scope. Where the practice is a subconsultant, coordination of the whole set and the other disciplines’ checks belong to the prime design professional. Record what was sent to them and what came back.

Fill the last column from the agency or client that governs the project. On private work there is often no client list. Use the contract scope and the permitting agency’s checklist.

Design phase Question to close before moving on Evidence to file Where the agency or client says what it expects
Pre-design Which jurisdictions, clients and approvals apply, and which code editions? Parcel information, list of approvals, code research note Agency’s pre-application guide
Concept or schematic Does anything in the concept depend on an approval or exception not yet confirmed? Written questions and the agency’s replies Preliminary review or pre-application service
Design development Have our sheets been checked against the rules identified, and are open items named? Where an earlier approval exists, do our sheets match its conditions and approved exhibits? Marked-up check set, open-items list with a named person for each, conditions list marked with the sheet that answers each Client’s phase deliverable list, conditions of approval
Construction documents, mid-point Do our sheets agree with the current civil, architectural and other backgrounds we were given? Coordination notes, with the date and version of each background Client’s or prime’s review procedure
Before submittal Does our part of the package meet the agency’s submittal checklist as published today, and are the code editions recorded at pre-design still the ones in force? Completed agency checklist items for our scope, with the checklist date Agency’s submittal checklist
After comments Is every comment on our scope answered, with the sheet where the change appears? Comment and response log Agency’s recheck procedure

For each checkpoint, record five things: the date, who checked, the document and edition checked against, what was found, and how each open item was closed. Give every open item a named person. Record whether it was closed by a change to the drawings, by the professional responsible for that scope with the basis noted, or by a written answer from the agency. A question of interpretation that only the agency can answer stays open until the agency answers it. The in-house reviewer’s opinion does not close it.

The codes article explains the edition check repeated in the fifth row. The permit submittals article gives a format for the comment and response log.

What we could not settle

  • Has GSA published a submittal matrix for the 2026 Core Building Standards? The posted matrix is labelled 2025 Interim.
  • What does the GSA matrix ask of community and landscape at each later phase? We read only a sample of its pages.
  • What do the Caltrans workflow tasks manual and the Landscape Architecture PS&E Guide add for planting and irrigation checks?
  • Which landscape-only scopes on school sites need DSA approval, and at which stage does DSA look at them?
  • What does the County of San Diego publish for pre-application review of landscape plans?
  • Is there published evidence that phase checkpoints reduce plan-check cycles on landscape projects? We found none.

Using this in Field Method

Site Dossier assembles a source-linked public-data record for a point in San Diego County: terrain, soils, water, fire hazard maps and climate, each with its source and date. It can sit beside the pre-design row as site background. It has no parcel or property lines, does not list jurisdictions, approvals or codes, and does not check a design against any code.

Sources

  1. U.S. General Services Administration — Core Building Standards for the Public Buildings Service
  2. U.S. General Services Administration — Memorandum: Rescission of PBS P100 Facilities Standards, and Issuance of PBS Interim Core Building Standards (February 24, 2025)
  3. U.S. General Services Administration — 2026 PBS Core Building Standards, with memorandum (September 21, 2026)
  4. U.S. General Services Administration — 2025 Interim Core Building Standards (CBS) Submittal Matrix, Version 1.0
  5. Caltrans — Project Development Procedures Manual, Chapter 8: Overview of Project Development (November 6, 2024)
  6. Caltrans — Project Development Procedures Manual, Chapter 29: Landscape Architecture (May 24, 2018)
  7. California Division of the State Architect — PR 24-01: Back Check Procedure for Design Professionals (issued October 16, 2024)
  8. California Division of the State Architect — PR 17-03: Project Submittal Appointment Process (revised February 11, 2019)
  9. California Division of the State Architect — DSA 3: Project Submittal Checklist (revised July 6, 2026, effective August 6, 2026)
  10. City of San Diego — Land Development Manual, Volume I, Chapter 1, Section 1: Guide to the Project Submittal Process (March 2023)
  11. City of San Diego — Information Bulletin 513: Preliminary Review (September 2026)
  12. City of San Diego — Land Development Manual, Volume I, Chapter 1, Section 4: Development Permits/Approvals (October 2024)
  13. County of San Diego Planning & Development Services — PDS 441A: How to Obtain a Building Permit (revised October 26, 2026)

These tools support site review and design studies. Read each tool’s stated capabilities and limits before use.

Explore Site Dossier
Back to Research