ResearchProfessional PracticeBuilding a Practice Research Library

Building a practice research library

Open research databases as each describes itself, how peer review and licences show on a record, and a filing routine that keeps DOIs, versions and dates.

Field Method · AI-assisted research roundupPublished Sources checked

Several public research databases are free to search. Finding a record is the short step. In our view the longer one is judging what it tells you and keeping the citation good enough that someone else can find the same document, in the same version, a year later. A record’s peer-review flag, licence line and identifier each mean only what the database that set them says they mean.

Below we describe six sources in their own terms, show where review status and reuse terms appear on a record, and set out a filing routine. The routine is ours. Everything else is taken from the pages linked, read on November 14, 2026. This is not legal advice.

These six are free, public sources we opened and read. They are not a full map of where landscape research is published. Journals of the field, general scholarly search and California agency libraries are not covered here.

What each source says it is

Landscape Performance Series. The Landscape Architecture Foundation (LAF) calls the series its product and defines landscape performance as a measure of how well landscape solutions fulfil their intended purpose. Its parts are Case Study Briefs, a Fast Fact Library, a Benefits Toolkit and Collections. LAF, About Landscape Performance The Case Study Briefs page describes a searchable database of over 200 built projects with quantified environmental, economic and social benefits, and gives no date for that count. It says LAF works with designers and academic research teams to document each project. LAF, Case Study Briefs LAF’s Case Study Investigation program pairs funded faculty and student teams with a firm liaison, and its page states that final case studies undergo a peer review process before publication to the series. The page does not say who reviews them or against what criteria. LAF, Case Study Investigation The Fast Fact Library describes itself as a searchable collection of landscape benefits drawn from published research, each with a citation and a link to the full article when available. LAF, Fast Fact Library

ERIC. ERIC describes itself as an internet-based bibliographic and full-text database of education research and information, sponsored by the Institute of Education Sciences of the US Department of Education. It needs no registration or subscription. ERIC FAQ Its selection policy, dated May 2024, says ERIC accepts both peer-reviewed and non-peer-reviewed material and aims to add full-text grey literature from non-journal sources such as research organizations and state and district research offices. ERIC Selection Policy

PubMed and PMC. PubMed describes itself as a free resource for searching biomedical and life sciences literature. Its About page, last updated March 11, 2025, says it holds more than 40 million citations and abstracts and does not include full-text journal articles. Its largest component is MEDLINE and its second largest is PubMed Central (PMC). About PubMed PMC describes itself as a free full-text archive of biomedical and life sciences journal literature at the National Library of Medicine (NLM). Its About page, last modified March 9, 2026, lists 11,327,616 articles available in fiscal year 2025. About PMC

DOAJ. The Directory of Open Access Journals indexes journals, and its application guide (Version 2.9) sets what a journal must show to be listed. Full text must be free without embargo or registration. The copyright holder must grant usage rights under an open licence, Creative Commons or equivalent, stated on the journal’s website. Every article must pass peer review before publication, with at least two independent reviewers, or two editors for arts and humanities journals. DOAJ, Guide to applying

Treesearch. The USDA Forest Service Research and Development page for Treesearch is a publication listing. On the day we read it the page showed 65,208 publications, including 30,187 labelled Scientific Journal and 10,859 General Technical Reports. The page carries no date and no description of scope. Treesearch

EPA’s publication library. The National Service Center for Environmental Publications (NSCEP) says visitors can search, retrieve and download EPA technical, scientific and educational publications free of charge. The page, last updated November 12, 2026, says NSCEP is moving to libraries.epa.gov. EPA NSCEP We did not read the USGS Publications Warehouse for this article and leave it out.

Our interpretation of where each fits: the LAF series is closest to built landscape work; Treesearch covers trees and forests, including urban trees; PubMed and PMC hold biomedical and health literature, one place to look for studies behind a claim about green space and wellbeing; ERIC holds education research relevant to school grounds and learning landscapes; DOAJ is a way to check a journal, and its listing criteria, before reading one of its articles. Absence from DOAJ is no mark against a journal: the criteria admit only fully open access journals, so subscription journals are outside its scope. None of these pages claims to cover all landscape architecture research.

How peer review shows on a record

Each database marks review differently. One does not mark it at all.

  • ERIC shows a “Peer reviewed” flag on the record. The record guide says the flag appears on all peer-reviewed journal article records. For non-journal records the guide says the flag might display back to 2002 for Institute of Education Sciences products, to 2013 for grantee submissions, and to the date the peer-review policy was adopted for other content. Guide to the ERIC Record The selection policy explains how the flag is set. For journals it is decided at the journal level and applied to every record from that journal. ERIC prefers at least two reviewers with scholarly affiliation and does not accept editorial review as peer review. For an individual’s submission, a statement by the author that the work is peer reviewed is not enough. ERIC Selection Policy
  • PubMed has no peer-review filter. NLM’s support article says a search cannot be limited to peer-reviewed journals, that NLM keeps no list of them, and that most journals indexed for PubMed are peer reviewed while criteria and reviewer qualifications vary. It suggests checking the journal’s editorial information. NLM support, KA-04151
  • PMC holds three kinds of content with different review status. Journal articles were formally published in scholarly journals. Author manuscripts have been peer reviewed and accepted by a journal. Preprints are made public before peer review. About PMC
  • DOAJ screens at the journal level through the criteria above. A DOAJ listing describes the journal’s stated process. It is not a review of any one article. DOAJ, Guide to applying
  • Treesearch labels each record “Formally Refereed” or “Informally Refereed”. On the day we read the listing, 22,021 records carried the first label and 43,187 the second. The page does not define either term. Treesearch For example, the urban tree database report PSW-GTR-253, from the Pacific Southwest Research Station in Albany, California, is labelled Informally Refereed. Treesearch record 52933 Without a definition, the label says only that the Forest Service classed it that way.
  • LAF states that Case Study Investigation case studies are peer reviewed, without describing the process. LAF, Case Study Investigation The Fast Fact Library page does not say that every source is peer reviewed. LAF, Fast Fact Library

In our interpretation, the practical rule is to record the status in the database’s own words together with the name of the database. “Peer reviewed (ERIC flag, journal level)” and “Informally Refereed (Treesearch)” say different things, and neither says the finding is right for your site.

How licence and reuse terms show on a record

Free to read is not the same as free to reuse. PMC says so directly: free access does not mean the content is free of copyright protection. About PMC

Creative Commons licences. Creative Commons lists six licences: CC BY, CC BY-SA, CC BY-NC, CC BY-NC-SA, CC BY-ND and CC BY-NC-ND. All six require credit to the creator. NC limits use to noncommercial purposes. ND allows copying only in unadapted form. SA requires adaptations to be shared under the same terms. Creative Commons, About CC Licenses The CC BY 4.0 deed says attribution means giving appropriate credit, linking to the licence and indicating whether changes were made. The deed says it is a summary and is not the licence itself. CC BY 4.0 deed CC0 is a different tool: the rights holder waives copyright, and no attribution is required. The Public Domain Mark is a label for works believed to be free of copyright worldwide. Creative Commons, Public Domain

Creative Commons describes noncommercial as not primarily intended for or directed towards commercial advantage or monetary compensation. Creative Commons, About CC Licenses A design practice works for fees. Whether a given use of an NC-licensed figure qualifies is a question for the licence text, the rights holder or counsel, and we do not answer it here.

Where the terms appear.

  • PMC: each article record has a “Copyright and License information” link. Where no statement is given, PMC says standard copyright protection is presumed. PMC warns that some journals label articles open access while applying traditional copyright, so check the terms on the article record. Author manuscripts added under a funder policy often carry no copyright statement or licence terms. PMC Copyright Notice
  • ERIC: the record guide lists a License field that gives the Creative Commons licence applied to the resource, and says the PDF icon is present when ERIC has permission to display the full text. Guide to the ERIC Record
  • DOAJ: a listed journal must state its licensing terms on its own website. DOAJ recommends, and does not require, that the licence be displayed or embedded in each article. DOAJ, Guide to applying DOAJ’s own journal and article metadata are offered under CC0. DOAJ, Terms and conditions
  • Federal reports: the Copyright Act says copyright protection is “not available for any work of the United States Government”, and defines such a work as one prepared by a federal officer or employee as part of official duties. US Copyright Office, Title 17, Chapter 1 That is not a blanket rule for everything in a federal database. PMC notes that photographs or illustrations inside public-domain government articles may be copyrighted by others. PMC Copyright Notice Treesearch lists journal articles alongside agency reports, and the record we read shows no copyright statement. Treesearch record 52933 Read the document itself.

DOIs, versions and corrections

What a DOI is. The DOI Foundation describes a DOI as a digital identifier of an object, made of a prefix and a suffix separated by a forward slash. It resolves through doi.org to the object’s current location, and the metadata can be updated without changing the DOI. The system is standardized as ISO 26324. DOI Foundation, What is a DOI? Crossref’s display guidelines say a DOI should always be shown as a full link in the form https://doi.org/10.xxxx/xxxxx, without a “doi:” prefix and without “dx” in the domain. Crossref, Display guidelines

Other identifiers. A PubMed identifier (PMID) is a unique number for each citation; the user guide says PMIDs do not change and are never reused. PubMed User Guide ERIC numbers begin with EJ for journal articles and ED for non-journal documents. Guide to the ERIC Record Forest Service reports carry a series number and often a DOI, for example PSW-GTR-253 and https://doi.org/10.2737/PSW-GTR-253. Treesearch record 52933

A DOI does not always fix a version. The DOI Handbook’s own DOI, 10.1000/182, is described as identifying the latest current version of the handbook. DOI Foundation, DOI Handbook Our interpretation: a DOI tells a reader where the object is now, so a citation that must be reproducible also needs the version and the date read.

Versions. Crossref’s guidance lists the stages of a research output: draft, preprint, pending publication, ahead of print, author accepted manuscript, version of record, and updated. It advises that a preprint has its own DOI, linked to the DOI of the later published work, and that an updated version receives a new DOI. For an editorially significant change, the original should not be modified. A separate notice of correction, update or retraction is published with its own DOI. For a retraction, “RETRACTED:” is added before the title in the original record. Crossref, Version control, corrections, and retractions NISO published a revised recommended practice on journal article version terms, RP-8-2026, on October 5, 2026, replacing the 2008 edition. The full text is linked from that page; we did not read it. NISO RP-8-2026

Checking for changes. Crossmark is a button on participating publishers’ pages and PDFs. Crossref’s page, last updated April 8, 2020, says one click shows whether the content has been corrected, retracted or otherwise updated. Crossref, Crossmark Crossref’s public REST API returns the registered metadata for a DOI without sign-up, including licence information and post-publication updates where the publisher supplied them. Crossref, REST API PubMed links citations to errata and retractions, with publication types such as Retracted Publication, Retraction Notice and Expression of Concern, and offers an “Exclude preprints” filter. PubMed User Guide Both checks depend on what the publisher registered. An empty result is not proof that nothing changed.

A filing routine (ours)

This is Field Method’s own method, drawn from the points above. It has not been tested in a practice.

One row per document, with these fields:

  1. Identifier. The DOI as a full https://doi.org/ link. Where there is none, the PMID, PMCID, ERIC number, or the agency series and report number.
  2. Citation. Authors, year, title, journal or issuing agency.
  3. Version read. Preprint, accepted manuscript, version of record, or the edition or revision number of a report.
  4. Where read. The page the file came from, since the repository copy and the publisher copy can differ in version.
  5. Review status, in the source’s words, and who says so. For example “Peer reviewed, ERIC flag” or “Informally Refereed, Treesearch”. Where the database is silent, as PubMed is, write “not stated” and the database name.
  6. Reuse terms. The licence name and link as shown on the article or record, or “no statement found”.
  7. Date published and date checked. The check date is the day someone opened the record and confirmed the fields above.
  8. What we took from it. The claim, with page, table or figure number, and its units and context: place, climate, sample.
  9. Update check. The date Crossmark, the publisher page or PubMed was last checked for a correction or retraction.

Three habits keep the rows current. Give each file a short name and record that name in the row, so the two cannot drift apart. A DOI cannot be a file name as written because it contains a slash. Recheck items 6, 7 and 9 before a figure from the document goes into a report, a submittal or a client presentation. When a claim comes from a summary, such as a Fast Fact or a case study brief, open the cited study and file that too, with the summary recorded as the route to it.

Organize by the design question. Tag each row with the question it answers, such as tree growth by region, and with the project that first used it. A later project can then see how old the check is.

Our articles on tracking regulatory updates and reading environmental product declarations cover the dates and validity periods those documents carry.

Limits

We read each database’s own description and did not test its search, coverage or records. Counts are as each page showed them. The copyright points are pointers to the source text and are not advice on any use.

What we could not settle

  • What do “Formally Refereed” and “Informally Refereed” mean in Treesearch? We found no current Forest Service page that defines them.
  • Who reviews LAF case studies, and against what criteria?
  • Which free indexes cover the landscape architecture journals themselves?
  • What reuse terms do state and local agency publications carry? The federal provision above does not cover them.
  • How many journals and articles does DOAJ list, and how does a licence show on a DOAJ article record? Its home page would not open for us.
  • Which version terms does NISO RP-8-2026 define, and how do they differ from Crossref’s stages? We did not read the full text.
  • How do the USGS Publications Warehouse, EPA’s new library site and California agency libraries describe their holdings and review?
  • Does the filing routine hold up in a working office?

Using this in Field Method

Site Dossier assembles public agency data for a point in San Diego County into a numbered site record. Its page says the record ends with an evidence register that lists every source with its date. It holds mapped public data only and does not hold research literature.

Sources

  1. Landscape Architecture Foundation — About Landscape Performance (Landscape Performance Series)
  2. Landscape Architecture Foundation — Case Study Briefs (Landscape Performance Series)
  3. Landscape Architecture Foundation — Case Study Investigation (CSI)
  4. Landscape Architecture Foundation — Fast Fact Library (Landscape Performance Series)
  5. ERIC — FAQ, General
  6. ERIC — ERIC Selection Policy (May 2024)
  7. National Library of Medicine — About PubMed (last update March 11, 2025)
  8. National Library of Medicine — About PMC (last modified March 9, 2026)
  9. DOAJ — Guide to applying (Version 2.9)
  10. USDA Forest Service Research and Development — Treesearch
  11. US EPA — National Service Center for Environmental Publications (NSCEP)
  12. ERIC — Guide to the ERIC Record (March 2025)
  13. NLM Customer Support Center — Are the journals in PubMed peer-reviewed? (KA-04151)
  14. USDA Forest Service Treesearch — McPherson, van Doorn and Peper (2016), Urban tree database and allometric equations, PSW-GTR-253
  15. Creative Commons — About CC Licenses
  16. Creative Commons — Attribution 4.0 International, deed
  17. Creative Commons — Public Domain (CC0 and the Public Domain Mark)
  18. National Library of Medicine — PMC Copyright Notice (last modified September 9, 2025)
  19. DOAJ — Terms and conditions (Version 1.6, December 8, 2025)
  20. US Copyright Office — Copyright Law of the United States, Chapter 1 (Circular 92)
  21. DOI Foundation — What is a DOI?
  22. Crossref — Display guidelines (last updated April 21, 2021)
  23. National Library of Medicine — PubMed User Guide (last update September 30, 2026)
  24. DOI Foundation — DOI Handbook (page updated December 10, 2025)
  25. Crossref — Version control, corrections, and retractions (last updated August 13, 2025)
  26. NISO — RP-8-2026, Journal Article Versions (JAV)
  27. Crossref — Crossmark (last updated April 8, 2020)
  28. Crossref — REST API

These tools support site review and design studies. Read each tool’s stated capabilities and limits before use.

Explore Site Dossier
Back to Research