An environmental product declaration (EPD) is a standardized summary of a product’s life-cycle assessment. A landscape architect usually meets one as a PDF from a manufacturer or a line in a database. The headline number is easy to copy. The conditions behind it decide whether the number can be used.
Estimating the carbon footprint of a landscape project covers the stages and the factors for concrete, asphalt, lumber and trees. This article does not repeat them. It covers how to read the document that carries such a factor, what a declaration leaves out, and what the rules say about comparing two products. It also covers health and sourcing declarations, which answer other questions. This is design-stage guidance. It is not procurement or legal advice.
Who writes the rules
Three layers sit behind an EPD. A program operator runs the system. A product category rule (PCR) sets the calculation rules for a category. A third-party verifier checks one declaration against both.
UL Solutions describes itself as an ISO 14025 program operator that provides third-party verification. It states that the LCA creator and the verifier are separate entities, and that a PCR may have to be written before an EPD for a new product type can start. UL Solutions
Program operators keep their own PCR libraries. EPD International adopts another operator’s PCR only under a mutual recognition arrangement. It sets PCR validity in a range of three to five years, with four years as the default, and a PCR can be the basis for an EPD only within its validity period. An expired PCR cannot be used to register a new EPD or to extend an existing one. EPD International, PCR development
Programs can still share a PCR. The NRMCA industry-average concrete EPD is published in the International EPD System, with EPD North America as licensee. It rests on NSF 1112-26 Concrete, Version 3.0, which was prepared by NSF and accepted by the International EPD System as an external PCR on July 29, 2026. The EPD gives that PCR’s validity as April 30, 2031. NRMCA EPD V4
We could not open ISO 14025 or ISO 21930 on the ISO site. What follows about their rules comes from the program documents that restate them.
Validity is a date range with caveats
Read the issue date, the validity date, the PCR and its version, and the program instructions version. The NRMCA EPD shows all of them in its opening pages: version date October 9, 2026, validity date October 9, 2031, NSF 1112-26 Version 3.0, and General Programme Instructions Version 5.0.1. It also says an EPD may be updated or depublished, so the program’s database is the place to confirm status. It states that follow-up of data during the validity period does not involve the third-party verifier. NRMCA EPD V4
Program instructions change too. EPD International’s page shows GPI 5.1 taking effect on November 10, 2026 and replacing 5.0.1. Published PCRs and EPDs keep their original validity, and during the transition an EPD can still be published under a PCR written for an earlier GPI if no newer PCR exists. EPD International, GPI In our reading, this means a valid EPD can sit on rules one or two generations old. That is permitted, and it is a reason to record the PCR version.
Buy Clean California adds a procurement test. An EPD must be valid when the material is installed, the program operator sets the expiry date shown in the EPD, and expired EPDs are not accepted. The Act applies to named state awarding authorities, including Caltrans, State Parks, the University of California, California State University and DGS. The page does not list local agencies, so a county or city project is outside it unless that agency adopts its own rule. The Act covers structural steel, concrete reinforcing steel, flat glass and insulation. DGS, Buy Clean California It does not list pavers, concrete or lumber. Its EPD rules are still a useful model for a landscape specification.
Declared unit and boundary
The declared unit tells you what one number measures. The NRMCA EPD declares one cubic metre of fresh concrete and gives a factor of 0.7645549 to convert a result to a US cubic yard. It is cradle-to-gate and reports modules A1 to A3. It says A4 may be reported separately under NSF 1112-26, and it does not report A5, B1 to B7, C1 to C4 or D. NRMCA EPD V4
A landscape quantity takeoff is in square metres, linear metres or each. The conversion is yours to make and to document. The EPD does not know the thickness, the base, the joints or the bedding.
The same EPD lists what its results leave out. They do not represent the full life cycle of concrete in a building or civil works. They do not quantify service life, durability, carbonation during use, maintenance, demolition, recycling or disposal, and carbonation removals are reported as not applicable. NRMCA EPD V4 Cradle-to-gate numbers describe the factory gate and no more.
Industry average or facility-specific
A declaration can describe one product from one plant, an average across a manufacturer’s plants, or an average across an industry. The NRMCA EPD is a sector EPD built from 1,238 facilities. It says these are about 20% of an estimated 6,500 US plants, and that this estimate counts plants and does not measure production volume. NRMCA EPD V4
Buy Clean California accepts only a facility-specific manufacturer declaration. It excludes industry-wide or industry-average declarations, fabricator declarations, and company-wide declarations that do not report each facility’s global warming potential separately. DGS, Buy Clean California
Building Transparency’s EC3 tool turns the same idea into numbers. It defines uncertainty for manufacturer, product, plant, supply chain and batch specificity, plus a residual 3% applied to every EPD. A product-line average counts as product uncertainty unless the products vary by less than 3% in GWP per declared unit. EC3 sorts by an uncertainty-adjusted value at the 80th percentile, and it notes that published EPDs rarely disclose their variance, so EC3 estimates it. EC3 Uncertainty Introduction The method rests on Waldman, Huang and Simonen (2020). They report that GWP varied by about 25% between the facilities of one five-facility EPD. They give default factors of plus or minus 2% when a specificity condition is met and 20% when it is not, and they say they picked the 20% value arbitrarily as a high estimate of unknown variation. They found no EPDs that published uncertainty data when they wrote. Waldman et al. 2020
Field Method interpretation: an industry average is a fair stand-in when you have no product, and a weak basis for choosing between two named products. EC3’s penalty is a design choice by Building Transparency. A forum or a procurement office may weigh it differently.
When two EPDs can be compared
The NRMCA EPD states the conditions in one passage, and it uses “shall”. For two EPDs to be comparable, they shall rest on the same PCR, including the same first-digit version, or on fully aligned PCRs. They shall cover products with identical function, performance and use, and identical declared units. They shall have the same life-cycle scope unless an excluded stage is shown to be insignificant. They shall use the same impact assessment method and characterization factor version, and both shall be valid at the time of comparison. It adds that EPDs from different programs may not be comparable. In its limitations, it also lists data quality, background datasets and allocation procedures as conditions for a comparison. NRMCA EPD V4
EC3’s criteria list further items that can break a comparison: LCI background data, data quality, use and end-of-life assumptions, allocation, and cut-off rules. EC3 says it does not yet treat allocation, cut-off rules, or use and end-of-life assumptions, and that data quality may be treated in future versions. It applies an uncertainty factor when an EPD uses a different impact method from the user’s default. It tracks PCR versions so that users can judge whether two EPDs share one. EC3, EPD Comparability
A short test follows from these sources. This test is our synthesis. Match the declared unit. Match the PCR and its version. Match the stages and the impact method. Check the validity dates. Compare the EPD type, and check that the product does the same job. If any step fails, say so in the specification notes and do not rank the products on the number.
A worked example: a paver EPD
We opened NSF EPD10351 for Superlite (an Oldcastle company), covering Belgard 60 mm and 80 mm solid concrete interlocking paving units made at two Arizona plants. We read it as extracted text, and read the results table from a rendered image. NSF EPD10351
Program and verification. The program operator is NSF Certification, LLC. The EPD was verified under ISO 14025 and ISO 21930:2007, with the LCA prepared by BASF and reviewed by Ecoform. The PCR is ASTM’s Segmental Concrete Paving Products, April 2015.
Validity. The date of issue is March 27, 2020 and the stated period is 5 years. By simple arithmetic that ends in March 2025. We did not check whether NSF’s listing shows a renewal, so treat this document as expired for any test that requires current validity. The cover page still shows template placeholders for the date and period, while the following pages give the real values.
Declared unit. One cubic metre of concrete formed into paving products. It is not a square metre of paving. The EPD says the PCR covers cradle-to-gate stages only. It lists cement at 250 to 300 kg per cubic metre as a range across the products covered.
Boundary. Modules A1 to A3: raw material supply, inbound transport, and manufacturing, including batching, forming, curing and packaging. It uses a 1% mass and energy cut-off, with at least 95% of energy and mass included. The database is GaBi, and impacts follow TRACI 2.1.
Result. From the results table: A1 3.86E+02, A2 1.09E+01 and A3 5.39E+00 kg CO2 eq per cubic metre, which we add to about 402. This is read from a small image, so confirm it against the source before using it. Our arithmetic, not the EPD’s: if a square metre of 80 mm paving were solid concrete, it would hold 0.08 m³, giving at most about 32 kg CO2e per m² for A1 to A3. At 60 mm the upper value is about 24 kg. Chamfers, spacer nibs and joints lower the solid volume, so use the manufacturer’s weight or volume per m² where it is published. Joint sand, bedding sand and base are not in either figure.
What is not declared. Delivery to site, installation, use, maintenance, end of life and the base course. The EPD says its results cannot be used to compare between products. A note on the results page says only cradle-to-grave EPDs with the same function, reference service life and functional unit, meeting ISO 14025 section 6.7.2, may support comparisons.
What it shows. Setting 402 beside the NRMCA mix values from the sibling article would mix two bases. The paver EPD uses a 2015 ASTM PCR, TRACI 2.1 for GWP and GaBi data. The NRMCA EPD uses a 2026 NSF PCR, IPCC AR5 100-year values for GWP, and USLCI and ecoinvent 3.10 data, and it keeps TRACI 2.1 only for one supplemental indicator. NRMCA EPD V4 The impact method alone fails the test above. The comparison would also set a manufactured paver beside ready-mix concrete. Most conditions fail, so we do not make that comparison.
Health and sourcing declarations answer different questions
None of the following replaces an EPD. Some EPDs carry a short content declaration. The NRMCA EPD lists its constituents, states that no substance on the ECHA Candidate List of Substances of Very High Concern is present above 0.1% by mass, and gives biogenic carbon content as zero. NRMCA EPD V4 That is limited content information. An EPD is not a health assessment or a sourcing certification.
Declare. The International Living Future Institute’s label lists ingredients at or above 100 ppm (0.01%) by weight, with chemical name, CAS number and percentage. It has three statuses. LBC Red List Free means full disclosure with no Red List chemicals. Red List Approved allows approved exceptions and a minimum of 99% disclosure. Declared means full disclosure with Red List chemicals present. A label license runs 12 months and can be renewed. ILFI Declare
Health Product Declarations. The HPD Collaborative released HPD Open Standard v3.0 in July 2025, effective September 2025, as a digital, modular format that screens ingredients by CAS or EC number and adds a PFAS attestation. Its repository labels HPDs as third-party prepared or third-party verified, so check which label an HPD carries. The v3.0 page we read gives no disclosure threshold. HPDC v3.0
FSC chain of custody. FSC describes chain of custody certification as the check that certified forest material stays traceable from the forest to the finished product. It applies at every step from sourcing to distribution, audits are done by accredited certification bodies, and FSC’s site offers a certificate search. Retailers that do not manufacture usually do not need it, but FSC says those selling certified building products that customers report to green building programs do. FSC A label tells you about fiber sourcing and control. It tells you nothing about embodied carbon, durability or end of life. Ask for the supplier’s certificate code and the claim on the invoice. The detailed labelling rules sit in FSC’s chain of custody standard, FSC-STD-40-004, which we did not read on an FSC International page.
Environmental claims on the label
The FTC’s Green Guides apply to marketing claims in the United States. They advise against unqualified claims such as “green”, and they say third-party certification does not relieve a marketer of substantiating the claims the certification communicates. A seal that does not show its basis should be paired with the specific benefit. FTC Green Guides summary For recycled content, 16 CFR 260.13 says unqualified claims can be made if the whole product, apart from minor incidental components, is made from recycled material. For a partly recycled item, it says the marketer “should clearly and prominently qualify the claim”, by amount or percentage by weight. 16 CFR 260.13 The Guides set out the FTC’s current views. They state they do not bind the FTC or the public, though the FTC can act under the FTC Act against a claim inconsistent with them, and they apply to business-to-business marketing as well. 16 CFR 260.1 They cover marketing, and they do not set specification rules. They are useful in one narrow way: a cut sheet that says “eco-friendly” without a declared basis has given you no data. Whether a given claim is lawful is a question for counsel.
Where data is missing
- Most EPD documents we read were cradle-to-gate. For landscape work, installation, maintenance interval and replacement are usually outside the declaration.
- Published EPDs rarely disclose their variance, according to Building Transparency, so the plus or minus on a headline number is usually unstated.
- An EPD gives no site information. Haul distance, local aggregate, and the thickness and base you design are yours to add and record.
- Health and sourcing programs use different thresholds and update on different cycles. A Declare label runs 12 months, and HPDs exist under more than one version of the HPD standard. Record the program version and date of each declaration.
- We did not find EPDs for every landscape material. A missing EPD is a gap in the file. It does not show a low impact.
Open questions
- What are the conditions of ISO 14025 section 6.7.2 and ISO 21930 clause 5.5 in the current standards, read directly?
- Does a current NSF listing show a renewed Superlite paver EPD, and how does it differ from the 2020 version?
- How much do paver, stone and wood EPDs vary between plants in the same region? We found no peer-reviewed study of that for landscape products.
- How many natural stone and site timber products have current EPDs at all? We did not survey them.
- Should a public landscape specification ask for facility-specific EPDs, as Buy Clean California does for its covered materials?
Using this in Field Method
Material Studio measures areas from a model and multiplies by the thickness you enter to give volumes. It does not read EPDs or calculate carbon. Use its quantities with the declared unit of the EPD, and record the program, PCR version, validity date and stages beside every figure you carry into a comparison.
Sources
- UL Solutions — Environmental Product Declarations Program
- EPD International — PCR development
- NRMCA — Member Industry-Average Ready Mixed Concrete EPD, Version 4 (2026)
- EPD International — General Programme Instructions
- California Department of General Services — Buy Clean California Act
- Building Transparency — Introduction to EC3 Uncertainty (February 16, 2023)
- Waldman, Huang and Simonen (2020) — Embodied carbon in construction materials: a framework for quantifying data quality in EPDs
- Building Transparency — EPD Comparability (EC3 methodology)
- NSF Certification — EPD10351, Superlite Belgard Concrete Interlocking Paving Units (2020)
- International Living Future Institute — Declare: the basics
- Health Product Declaration Collaborative — HPD Open Standard v3.0
- Forest Stewardship Council — Chain of Custody Certification
- US Federal Trade Commission — Environmental Claims: Summary of the Green Guides
- eCFR — 16 CFR 260.13, Recycled content claims
- eCFR — 16 CFR 260.1, Purpose, scope, and structure of the guides
Try a relevant tool
These tools support site review and design studies. Read each tool’s stated capabilities and limits before use.
Explore Material Studio