A landscape project is decided by more people than the client and the design team. Agencies approve it, utilities and neighbors are affected by it, consultants share its documents, and on public work a community expects a say. Our reading of the sources is that coordination depends on five things: what decision is open, who has a stake in it, how much influence each party is being offered, which steps the law requires, and where the outcome is written down.
The public guidance on this subject was written for government agencies. EPA describes its Public Participation Guide as “designed with government agencies in mind”, and as a primer that will not replace training or expert help. EPA publishes it in its international cooperation pages, and the introduction speaks of participation “throughout the world”. It is a general primer. It does not present itself as a rule for US projects. EPA, Introduction to the Guide A landscape architect usually works for such an agency, or for an applicant in front of one. This article reports what the sources say and then adapts them for a design team. The adaptations are ours and are labeled. Nothing here is legal advice.
Start with the decision
EPA’s first planning step concerns the decision itself. Before inviting anyone, confirm that the public can influence the outcome, that the decision-makers are committed, and where constraints limit input. The guide warns against “merely seeking public buy-in” for a settled outcome. EPA, Process Planning
Our adaptation. Ask the client three things before the first meeting: what is already fixed, what is open, and who makes the final call. A park whose program was set by a funding grant has less open than one starting from a blank brief. Say so at the start.
Map the stakeholders
What the sources say. EPA calls the mapping step a situation assessment and gives it two phases. In the internal phase, the agency clarifies the problem, the decision and its resources, and drafts a first stakeholder list. In the external phase, it interviews a broad range of stakeholders, starting with those already known, and asks each who else should be contacted. When new names become scarce, most key stakeholders have probably been found. The interviews cover how each party sees the issues, who is needed for implementation, who could block it, what role each wants, and how each prefers to receive information. EPA, Situation Assessments
California’s General Plan Guidelines give a list of stakeholder groups for a general plan. It includes community and neighborhood groups, school districts, utilities and public service providers for energy, water, telecommunications and waste, state and federal partners, business, civic organizations, existing boards and commissions such as parks and recreation, other public agencies, and tribal leaders. The chapter adds that communication should be in the major languages spoken in the community. OPR, General Plan Guidelines, Chapter 3 A site project will use part of that list.
Our adaptation: a stakeholder map. One row per party, with these columns:
| Column | What it holds |
|---|---|
| Party and contact | Organization, named person, how they prefer to be reached |
| Role | Decides, approves or permits, advises, is affected, or delivers the work |
| Interest | What they care about, in their words where possible |
| Authority | The specific approval, comment or recommendation they give, and its source |
| Level offered | How much influence they are being offered (next section) |
| Required step | Any notice, hearing or review the law or agency requires for them |
| Last contact | Date and link to the record |
The Authority column separates required approval from advice. Fill it from the agency’s own rules.
State the level of influence
EPA’s guide uses the Public Participation Spectrum developed by the International Association for Public Participation (IAP2). IAP2 USA describes it as a range of roles the public can have in a decision process. Its page says to contact the IAP2 Federation for permission to use the Spectrum, so we describe it and do not reproduce it. IAP2 USA
As EPA explains it, the Spectrum has five levels: inform, consult, involve, collaborate and empower. Each pairs a goal with a promise to the public. At the inform level the promise is only to keep people informed. At consult, the agency promises to consider input and report back on how it affected the decision. At empower, the agency promises to implement what the public decides. EPA’s advice is to begin by asking how much influence the agency is willing to give, and it observes that most meaningful participation happens at the consult, involve and collaborate levels. EPA, Selecting the Right Level
Two cautions in the guide matter for consultants. Agencies often promise more influence than is likely or possible, and stakeholders who expected more than they received will be dissatisfied whatever the amount of activity. The planning page adds that an agency should never commit to a level higher than its decision-makers will deliver. EPA, Process Planning In our view the level is the client’s promise to make, and the design team should get it stated before a workshop is advertised.
EPA groups tools by purpose: tools to inform, tools to generate and obtain input, and tools for consensus building and agreement seeking. EPA, Tools Its planning page asks for a clear objective for each interaction before tools are chosen. EPA, Process Planning
What is required and what is good practice
Required steps depend on the kind of decision, the funding and the place. The examples below are not a complete list. The agency or counsel should confirm what applies to a project.
General plans in California. The General Plan Guidelines report that state law requires the planning agency to provide opportunities for involvement by citizens, tribes, public agencies, utilities and community groups (Government Code Section 65351), and at least two public hearings before adoption, one by the planning commission and one by the legislative body. They also report that local governments must consult with traditionally affiliated California Native American tribes when a general plan is adopted or amended, or open space is designated. That duty sits with the local government. The chapter then places these statutory requirements in the inform area of the Spectrum and notes that many jurisdictions do more. OPR, General Plan Guidelines, Chapter 3 The publishing office says the Guidelines were last updated comprehensively in 2017. Governor’s Office of Land Use and Climate Innovation, General Plan Guidelines We read the statutes only as the 2017 Guidelines report them, and they may have changed since.
Federally funded transportation. We include two federal rules because streetscape and trail work is sometimes built with federal highway funds. They work at two scales. At the plan scale, a metropolitan planning organization must have a documented participation plan for its metropolitan transportation plan and transportation improvement program. The plan must provide adequate notice, time for comment at key decision points, and “explicit consideration and response to public input”. 23 CFR 450.316 This rule governs the regional plan and program. It does not set a process for a single project. At the project scale, for the Federal-aid highway program, each state must have FHWA-approved public involvement procedures. They provide for one or more public hearings, or the opportunity for one, on projects with specified effects, and for a transcript of each hearing to be sent to FHWA. The rule places the hearing with the State highway agency. 23 CFR 771.111 Our reading is that the designer supports that process and does not run it. The funding agency says whether a project is covered and which procedures apply.
City of San Diego development permits. The Municipal Code sets five decision processes. In Process One, staff decide and no public hearing is held. In Process Two, staff decide after a mailed Notice of Future Decision, with an appeal hearing available. Processes Three, Four and Five are decided at noticed public hearings by a Hearing Officer, the Planning Commission and the City Council. Capital improvement program projects are excepted. They follow a separate division of the code (Chapter 11, Article 2, Division 6), which we did not read in detail. The code also notes that other agencies, such as the State Coastal Commission, may require their own processes. SDMC Chapter 11, Article 2, Division 5 The notice division says who receives mailed notice: the applicant, tenants on the property, tenants and property owners within 300 feet of it, the officially recognized community planning groups for the area, and anyone who asked in writing. It adds airport bodies in the Airport Land Use Compatibility Overlay Zone. It allows a newspaper display advertisement in place of mailing above 1,000 tenants and owners, except for a Coastal Development Permit. The applicant posts the Notice of Application or Notice of Future Decision on the property. The City mails and publishes the Notice of Public Hearing. SDMC Chapter 11, Article 2, Division 3 The permit type sets the process, so the first coordination question on a San Diego project is which process applies. Our article on tracking regulatory updates covers the City’s email lists, which include public notices by community.
Advisory review: community planning groups. San Diego’s Council Policy 600-24 defines recognized community planning groups as “independent advisory bodies” to the City. They may make advisory recommendations on land use matters in their area, and the policy states that the City “is not bound to follow the advice” given. It also says private project applicants “are not required by this policy to present” to a group, while the City encourages them to engage with groups, the community and neighbors. Groups must comply with the Brown Act’s open meeting rules, with one stated exception for teleconferenced meetings. They must keep agendas, minutes and other official records for at least five years, and send a project recommendation to the City within seven calendar days of approving it. The City may decline to review a recommendation sent eight or more calendar days after approval. Council Policy 600-24 The City describes the groups’ recommendations as integral to the planning process and publishes a contact list and meeting agendas. City of San Diego, Community Planning Groups
The San Diego example separates three things that are easy to blur. Mailed notice, posted notice and a public hearing are steps the code requires where the process that applies calls for them. The planning group’s recommendation is advisory, and the policy does not require a private applicant to seek it. A neighborhood workshop held by the design team is neither. It is good practice, and it does not replace either of the first two.
Good practice. FHWA says participation is worth more when it is “open, relevant, timely, and appropriate for the intended goal”, and that input should be sought at key points where it can shape the decision. FHWA, Public Involvement Its page on virtual tools says they can make participation more convenient for more people and are not intended to completely replace in-person opportunities. FHWA, Virtual Public Involvement
Coordinating with agencies and consultants
Three provisions are useful here.
- Early agency coordination. The federal highway rule states that early coordination with agencies and the public helps decide the type and scope of environmental documents, and contributes to reducing delay, duplication and conflict. 23 CFR 771.111
- Written roles and decision points. The planning rule asks metropolitan planning organizations, to the extent practicable, to document a process that outlines “roles, responsibilities, and key decision points” for consulting other governments and agencies. It also requires that tribal governments and federal land management agencies be involved in developing the regional plan and program where their lands are in the planning area. 23 CFR 450.316
- One party responsible for coordinating documents. For building permits, San Diego makes the architect or engineer of record responsible for reviewing and coordinating submittal documents “prepared by others” for compatibility with the design of the building. The section is a building permit rule and names only the architect or engineer of record. SDMC Chapter 12, Article 9, Division 2
Our adaptation. Write down each consultant’s and agency’s role, the decisions each must make or approve, and the date each is needed. Name one person who coordinates documents across disciplines, and confirm with the building department who the code treats as responsible on the project. Ask each agency early which process applies and who its contact is. End each meeting with the decisions made, the items still open, and who owes what by when.
Recording decisions
What the sources require or advise. The metropolitan planning rule requires “a summary, analysis, and report on the disposition of comments” as part of the final regional plan and program when significant comments are received on the drafts. 23 CFR 450.316 The highway rule requires a hearing transcript with the written statements received. 23 CFR 771.111 The General Plan Guidelines list “methods available to capture and record dialogue” among the matters to plan for. They advise a mechanism for telling people who took part how their input was used. OPR, General Plan Guidelines, Chapter 3 San Diego’s policy requires planning groups to keep minutes and to record and post their project recommendations in a uniform way. Council Policy 600-24
Our adaptation: three records. None of these formats comes from the sources above.
- Contact record. For each meeting, call or letter: date, who took part, what was asked, what was said, and what was promised.
- Comment register. One row per comment from an agency, consultant or member of the public: source, date, the comment, the response, the resulting change to the design if any, and the reason where no change is made.
- Decision log. One row per decision:
| Field | What it holds |
|---|---|
| Decision | What was decided, in one sentence |
| Date and decider | Who had the authority and when they used it |
| Options considered | The alternatives that were on the table |
| Input considered | Which parties were heard, with links to the contact record or comment register |
| Basis | The reason given, including any code, permit condition or budget limit |
| Status | Final, provisional, or required to be confirmed by a named agency |
| Follow-up | Who was told, and what changes in the drawings |
Keep required records separate from these. The agency’s notices, hearing records and conditions of approval are the official record. A team’s log does not prove that a legal step was met.
What we could not settle
- What do CEQA and NEPA require for notice and comment on the kinds of projects landscape architects lead? We did not read those rules at source.
- What does the Brown Act text require of advisory bodies other than San Diego’s planning groups? We read it only as Council Policy 600-24 and the General Plan Guidelines describe it.
- What is the current form of the IAP2 Spectrum, and is a revision pending? The IAP2 Federation page did not open for us.
- San Diego’s notice division, last amended by Ordinance O-22109 effective July 15, 2026, and its decision process division, dated 2-2025, give different mailing deadlines for the Notice of Application. They also differ on the waiting period after a Notice of Future Decision. Which governs?
- What does the City’s separate decision process for capital improvement program projects (Chapter 11, Article 2, Division 6) require? We did not read it in detail.
- What does the City’s Information Bulletin 620 add for applicants and planning groups? Council Policy 600-24 names its distribution form. We did not read the bulletin.
- How do the County of San Diego and other cities handle advisory community review?
- Does any public agency publish a decision log or comment register format for design consultants? We found none in these sources.
- When the client is a public agency, do a consultant’s contact records and comment register become public records? We did not read the law on this.
- What do FHWA’s detailed technique publications add? Its publications page did not open for us.
Using this in Field Method
Site Dossier assembles public data for a point in San Diego County into a source-linked site record. It does not track stakeholders, meetings or decisions. It can give the parties one shared description of existing conditions. Keep the stakeholder map and decision log beside it.
Sources
- US EPA — Public Participation Guide: Introduction to the Guide
- US EPA — Public Participation Guide: Process Planning
- US EPA — Public Participation Guide: Situation Assessments
- California Governor's Office of Planning and Research — General Plan Guidelines, Chapter 3: Community Engagement and Outreach
- IAP2 USA — IAP2 Core Values, Ethics, Spectrum
- US EPA — Public Participation Guide: Selecting the Right Level of Public Participation
- US EPA — Public Participation Guide: Tools
- California Governor's Office of Land Use and Climate Innovation — General Plan Guidelines and Technical Advisories
- eCFR — 23 CFR 450.316, Interested parties, participation, and consultation
- eCFR — 23 CFR 771.111, Early coordination, public involvement, and project development
- City of San Diego — Municipal Code Chapter 11, Article 2, Division 5: Decision Process (2-2025)
- City of San Diego — Municipal Code Chapter 11, Article 2, Division 3: Notice (9-2026)
- City of San Diego — Council Policy 600-24, Standard Operating Procedures and Responsibilities of Recognized Community Planning Groups (effective May 29, 2024)
- City of San Diego — Community Planning Groups
- Federal Highway Administration — Public Involvement
- Federal Highway Administration — Virtual Public Involvement
- City of San Diego — Municipal Code Chapter 12, Article 9, Division 2: Building Permit Procedures (9-2026)
Try a relevant tool
These tools support site review and design studies. Read each tool’s stated capabilities and limits before use.
Explore Site Dossier