ResearchSustainable DesignLandscape Sustainability Rating Systems

Landscape sustainability rating systems compared: SITES, LEED, Envision and LBC

What SITES, LEED, Envision and the Living Building Challenge cover, how each scores, who administers them, and what a level does and does not show.

Field Method · AI-assisted research roundupPublished Sources checked

Four programs come up most often when a landscape project is asked to carry a rating: SITES, LEED, Envision and the Living Building Challenge. Each turns a long list of design and management actions into a score or a count of requirements met. They differ in what they list, who reviews the evidence, when the review happens and what a level means. The administrators’ own documents show four different structures. They differ in what they certify, when evidence is reviewed, and whether measured performance is required before a level is awarded.

This article compares structure and stated scope as the administrators publish them, read on November 14, 2026. It does not rank the programs. Statements about what the structures imply are labelled interpretation. Requirements, fees and versions change, and the programs are not interchangeable. This is not legal or professional advice.

What each program certifies

The first decision on a park, plaza or streetscape is whether the program can certify a site with no building.

Versions open as of November 14, 2026

As read on the source check date:

  • SITES: v2. GBCI released addenda that projects registered after January 6, 2025 must follow, according to ASLA.
  • LEED: v5 is the latest version and is available for BD+C, ID+C and O+M. The LEED page says to register v5 projects in Arc and v4.1 and v4 projects in LEED Online. We found no registration close date for v4.1 on these pages. Check with USGBC.
  • Envision: v3 is the version described in every ISI document we could open, including the v3 FAQ. We make no statement about v4. Check with ISI.
  • LBC: 4.1. ILFI’s X.1 update launched on April 4, 2024, and registration under earlier versions closed on June 30, 2024.

What is free to read

SITES. The SITES v2 rating system and scorecard are described as free downloads, and registered projects get worksheets and calculators. The resources page sells the SITES v2 Reference Guide. Its English rating system link goes to a USGBC resource page that did not show the file when opened without signing in. We read the Spanish edition of the SITES v2 rating system, which sustainablesites.org hosts openly, for credit-level detail.

LEED. GBCI verifies and reviews LEED projects. We read the LEED v5 BD+C Reference Guide, July 2026 edition, which is open on usgbc.org.

Envision. The Institute for Sustainable Infrastructure (ISI) runs Envision. Its policies, updated May 2024, say the Guidance Manual is available from a user’s ISI dashboard. We did not read the manual, and we relied on ISI PDFs.

LBC. The International Living Future Institute (ILFI) runs LBC. Its program changes page says the 4.1 program manual is public at no cost. We could not open it. We read the LBC 4.0 standard that ILFI hosts, which is superseded.

SITES v2

Scope. The certification guide sets a minimum of 2,000 square feet (185.8 square meters), no maximum, and asks projects over 100 acres to contact GBCI.

Structure. SITES describes v2 as 18 prerequisites and 48 credits worth up to 200 points, in ten sections. The same overview states four goals: regenerative systems and resilience, future resource supply and climate mitigation, market transformation through design, development and maintenance practice, and human well-being and community. The Spanish edition adds that prerequisites carry no points and every credit is optional. Nine sections carry the 200 base points: site context, pre-design assessment and planning, site design for water, site design for soil and vegetation, site design for materials selection, site design for human health and well-being, construction, operations and maintenance, and education and performance monitoring. A tenth, innovation or exemplary performance, offers 3 to 9 bonus points above the 200.

Levels, as the certification guide states them. Certified is 70 to 84 points. Silver is 85 to 99. Gold is 100 to 134. Platinum is 135 or more.

Weighting. A 2023 case study of Navy Pier reports the maximum points by section as site context 13, pre-design 3, water 23, soil and vegetation 40, materials 41, human health 30, construction 17, operations and maintenance 22, and education and monitoring 11. By our arithmetic these add to 200. A credit gives a range of points by performance level. In the 2014 Spanish edition, managing rainfall beyond the baseline earns 4, 5 or 6 points for the 80th, 90th or 95th percentile event. Check the current addenda before relying on any credit requirement.

Review. The guide describes a standard path with a full application after construction and a split path with part of the submission at the end of design. Preliminary, final and appeal reviews are each listed at 20 to 25 business days. GBCI or any third party can challenge a certification within 18 months. GBCI charges separate registration and certification fees, with member rates and an optional precertification review. See the certification guide for current figures. The page carries no date.

Edition. The Spanish edition carries a 2014 copyright and calls itself the first edition. GBCI’s addenda table, with entries dated October 4, 2024, amends requirement text in several credits. Examples are the biomass density values in C4.8, the vegetated-roof factor in C4.9 (0.5 becomes 0.75) and the electric charging minimum in C6.9. In our reading of every entry, it changes no point values.

LEED v5 BD+C

Structure. The July 2026 reference guide gives 110 possible points for new construction. By category they are integrative process, planning and assessments 1, location and transportation 15, sustainable sites 11, water efficiency 9, energy and atmosphere 33, materials and resources 18, indoor environmental quality 13, and project priorities 10. Every prerequisite and credit is also mapped to impact areas: decarbonization, quality of life, and ecological conservation and restoration.

Levels. USGBC’s commercial certification guide lists 40 to 49 points as Certified, 50 to 59 as Silver, 60 to 79 as Gold and 80 or more as Platinum, with additional requirements for v5 Platinum. Appendix I of the reference guide sets them for new construction: five points in Electrification, eight in Enhanced Energy Efficiency, 100 percent of site energy from Tier 1 to 3 renewable energy, and a 20 percent embodied carbon reduction. Core and Shell has its own set. In v5, Platinum is not a points threshold alone.

Landscape content. The sustainable sites category has one prerequisite and six credits. The prerequisite, Minimize Site Disturbance, requires an erosion and sedimentation control plan that conforms to the 2022 EPA Construction General Permit or another listed equivalent. The guide says projects must apply the permit regardless of size. It also requires a preconstruction site survey or assessment that informs the design, and conservation of all special-status vegetation on site, as local, state or federal entities define it. The credits are biodiverse habitat (2 points), accessible outdoor space (1), rainwater management (3), enhanced resilient site design (2), heat island reduction (2) and light pollution reduction (1). Credits in other categories also touch landscape work, such as compact and connected development. We did not review them.

Links to SITES. The guide refers to SITES v2 in places. For example, under drought in enhanced resilient site design, water makeup for created water features must comply with SITES C3.4 or a local equivalent. GBCI also publishes a LEED v5 and SITES v2 crosswalk of one-way and two-way credit synergies.

Fees. USGBC says registration follows the fee schedule published at registration, and certification fees depend on floor area, rating system and review type.

Envision v3

Background. The Envision packet of April 2024 describes ISI as founded by APWA, ASCE and ACEC, with Envision developed together with the Zofnass Program at the Harvard Graduate School of Design.

Structure. The packet counts 64 credits in five categories: quality of life 14, leadership 12, resource allocation 14, natural world 14 and climate and resilience 10. The 2018 v3 FAQ gives a maximum of 1,000 points and awards by share of applicable points. Verified is 20 percent, Silver 30, Gold 40 and Platinum 50. Applicable points depend on which credits apply to a project. Each credit has up to five levels of achievement, from Improved to Restorative. The ISI policies describe an award as a score of at least 20 percent.

Process. The FAQ says Envision is primarily a self-assessment tool and that third-party verification is optional. ISI’s packet describes two verification pathways, one during design and one after construction. The FAQ ties them to 95 percent design completion or 95 percent construction completion, and says a design-phase award needs a post-construction review to be maintained. Confirm current fees with ISI.

Comparison help. In April 2025 ISI published a credit-by-credit comparison of LEED v5 BD+C and Envision v3. It says that, because the project types differ, credits rarely map one to one. ISI also publishes a side-by-side overview of 6 infrastructure, 7 community and 21 building systems. It names other programs, among them BREEAM Infrastructure, which it describes as covering landscaping and public realm projects. Both documents come from the administrator of one of the systems compared.

Living Building Challenge

Version. The support page says Core certification became a pathway within LBC at 4.1, and that ILFI publishes minor manual updates in January, April, July and/or October.

Scope. In the 4.0 standard, the landscape or infrastructure typology covers projects with no enclosed structure in the primary program, including parks, roads, bridges, plazas, sports facilities and trails.

Structure. LBC has seven performance areas called petals: place, water, energy, health and happiness, materials, equity and beauty. The 4.0 standard divides them into 20 imperatives. Living Certification requires every imperative assigned to the project’s typology. For a new building that is all 20. Other typologies have scope-dependent sets. Petal certification in 4.0 required the ten core imperatives and all imperatives in the water, energy or materials petal. We could not confirm how 4.1 states these rules.

Scoring. LBC has no point total. Compliance is based on actual performance, and the 4.0 standard requires at least twelve consecutive months of operation before the audit. LBC Ready recognition can be awarded before the twelve months, but the standard says it is not certification. We did not check how the twelve-month rule applies to the landscape typology in 4.1.

Fees. ILFI’s registration page lists fees for building projects, effective October 1, 2026. It does not list the landscape and infrastructure typology. Confirm fees with ILFI.

Comparing the structures

Interpretation. Each program sets its own thresholds over a different set of credits and prerequisites, so a level in one says nothing about a level in another. Comparing thresholds as shares of points misleads. SITES adds bonus points above its total, LEED v5 adds credit conditions for Platinum, and Envision scores against applicable points only.

Weights show scope. In SITES, soil and vegetation and materials carry 40 and 41 of the 200 base points. In LEED v5 BD+C, the whole sustainable sites category carries 11 points and energy and atmosphere carries 33. Envision gives each of its categories 10 to 14 credits, but credit counts are not point weights. In our reading, these patterns reflect what each administrator treats as central. SITES is built around the site. LEED BD+C is built around a building. Envision is built around infrastructure assets, and LBC around a place that must perform.

What a score shows

The reviews happen at different moments. SITES reviews documentation after construction, or at the end of design and again after construction. Envision verification can occur at 95 percent design. LBC audits after at least twelve months of operation in the 4.0 standard. LEED v5 lists Project Impact Reports as coming soon for BD+C, ID+C and O+M. USGBC describes LEED O+M, for existing buildings, as focused on ongoing operations, maintenance and performance. O+M is outside this comparison.

For landscapes, the Navy Pier case study is the one academic source we could open. It describes itself as primarily a literature review of the project’s SITES scorecard. It reports performance figures as given by the designer and other parties, not from its own measurement. The authors say research on SITES v2 is lacking. We found no published study we could read that compares certification level with measured landscape outcomes for any of the four programs.

Interpretation. A level states that a team earned a set of credits that the reviewer accepted at one time. Because credits beyond prerequisites are optional, two projects at the same level can hold different strengths. Of the systems compared here (SITES v2, LEED v5 BD+C, Envision v3 and LBC 4.0), only LBC requires twelve months of measured operation before certification. For a client, the useful question is which credits the project earned and what evidence stood behind each.

Questions for the project team

  • Does the program certify a site with no building, or does site work earn credits within a building’s rating?
  • Which version, edition and addenda apply at the registration date?
  • Which credits will the project earn, and what evidence will the reviewer accept?
  • Which fees apply, according to the administrator’s current page?
  • Which outcomes will the team measure after construction, beyond what the program requires?

SITES and the LEED v5 prerequisite both start from a pre-design site assessment. A public-data site record, such as Field Method’s Site Dossier for San Diego County, can start that work. It is not a survey and does not by itself meet any prerequisite.

Limits and open questions

We did not read the English SITES v2 rating system, the SITES v2 Reference Guide, the Envision Guidance Manual, the LBC 4.1 program manual or the LEED v4.1 documents. Other systems, among them BREEAM Infrastructure and programs for roads and parking, were not examined. ISI’s web pages could not be opened, so Envision v4 status is not reported. Credit-level point values for SITES come from the 2014 edition. No fee figures are given. No reviewed study compares the programs on measured landscape outcomes.

Sources

  1. Sustainable SITES Initiative — Administration and LEED v5 and SITES v2 synergies crosswalk notice (Oct 9, 2025)
  2. Sustainable SITES Initiative — SITES rating system (certification guide)
  3. International Living Future Institute — Living Building Challenge
  4. ISI — Envision: The Blueprint for Sustainable Infrastructure (packet)
  5. USGBC — LEED rating system
  6. ASLA — SITES v2 Rating System Addenda Now Available
  7. USGBC — LEED v5 product page
  8. ISI — Envision v3: What You Need to Know and Frequently Asked Questions
  9. Living Future — Program Changes and Sunset Date FAQs
  10. Sustainable SITES Initiative — Get started with the SITES v2 rating system
  11. Sustainable SITES Initiative — Resources (rating system resources)
  12. Sustainable SITES Initiative — SITES v2 Rating System, Spanish edition (Sistema de clasificación SITES v2)
  13. USGBC — LEED v5 Reference Guide for Building Design and Construction, July 2026 Edition
  14. ISI — ISI Policies (updated May 2024)
  15. International Living Future Institute — Living Building Challenge 4.0 standard
  16. Sustainable SITES Initiative — The SITES Rating System (one-page overview)
  17. Jin and Wang (2023) — The practice and potential of the SITES v2 rating system for the sustainable design of a landscape: a case study of Chicago's Navy Pier
  18. Sustainable SITES Initiative — SITES v2 Addenda Table
  19. USGBC — Guide to LEED Certification: Commercial
  20. ISI — Envision v3 and LEED v5 credit comparison
  21. ISI — Sustainability Rating and Certification Systems comparison (2025)
  22. International Living Future Institute — Project Registration Details (pricing effective October 1, 2026)

These tools support site review and design studies. Read each tool’s stated capabilities and limits before use.

Explore Site Dossier
Back to Research