A cost figure given early in design is a range. The class of an estimate follows from how well the project is defined. Published ranges show how accuracy typically narrows as definition improves. AACE says the range for a project should come from a risk analysis of that project. Some public owners set a contingency percentage for each milestone of their own projects. A public bid price is evidence about one contract on one date.
We read every source on November 14 and 15, 2026. This is not financial or legal advice, and requirements differ by owner, agency and contract.
An estimate class describes how much is defined
AACE International’s general classification uses the maturity of the project definition deliverables as its primary characteristic. End use, method, and the effort needed are secondary. AACE 17R-97
Its companion for building and general construction, 56R-08, says it is meant for buildings and for site and civil projects such as site development, utility infrastructure and storm water work. It says it does not address transportation infrastructure. It describes itself as a guideline and not a standard. AACE 56R-08
The practice sorts estimates into five classes by the maturity of the defining deliverables, from Class 5, the least defined, to Class 1. Its matrix gives each class a typical use, method and expected accuracy range. We do not reproduce the matrix; it is in the AACE document. The text says a Class 5 estimate for a building or general construction project may have a range as broad as −30 to +50 percent or as narrow as −20 to +30 percent. AACE 56R-08
The same document adds four qualifications. The deliverables decide the class, not a percentage of design complete. The ranges describe how actual cost varies from the estimate for a given scope, after a contingency that typically makes an overrun and an underrun equally likely. They are stated at an 80 percent confidence interval: with contingency set appropriately, about 80 percent of projects should fall within them. And the range for a project should come from a risk analysis of that project and never be set in advance. For weak project systems and complex or risky projects, the document says research indicates the high side may be two to three times the matrix figure. AACE 56R-08 Our reading: the ranges do not cover a change in scope.
Roads and rail have their own practice, 98R-18, which notes that stage names differ widely between agencies. The free preview stops before its matrix. AACE 98R-18
Our interpretation: a park, campus or plaza estimate fits the building and general construction practice, and a streetscape in a public right-of-way sits nearer the road practice. In the pages we read, neither names landscape architecture. An estimate should state which matrix it was classed against.
How three public owners map design phase to the estimate
GSA. The Public Buildings Service policy, P-120, cites ASTM E2516 for five classes and assigns a class to each estimate stage. Screening is Class 5. Planning and program development are Class 4. Concept design is Class 3. Design development is Class 2. Construction documents are Class 1. Lump sums and allowances are limited to under 15 percent at 50 percent design development, falling to none at final construction documents. Early stages are organized by Uniformat and later ones by MasterFormat. A second table in the policy lists design development under both Class 3 and Class 2, so a phase name alone does not fix the class. GSA P-120
Washington State DOT. Its February 2026 manual has a matrix by phase: planning at 0 to 2 percent design, −50 to +200 percent; pre-design at 1 to 15 percent, −40 to +100; scoping at 10 to 30 percent, −30 to +50; design at 30 to 90 percent, −10 to +25; and plans, specifications and estimate at 90 to 100 percent, −5 to +10. WSDOT M 30-34.04
Caltrans. Chapter 20 of its procedures manual names the estimates instead of numbering them: project feasibility, project initiation, draft project report, project report, preliminary engineer’s and final engineer’s. It states a recommended contingency for each and no accuracy range. Caltrans PDPM Chapter 20
The early WSDOT ranges are far wider than the Class 5 span AACE gives for building work. The two are not on one basis. The AACE practice excludes transportation work and states its ranges for a given scope, after contingency. We found no such basis stated with the WSDOT matrix, and no source that reconciles the two.
Contingency, by source
GSA follows ASTM E2168 in separating three sums. An allowance covers a planned item until it can be better defined. A contingency covers occurrences that are unintended and not directly controllable. A reserve is held by management for unforeseen changes in project requirements. GSA notes that, in those terms, its design contingency is technically an allowance for completing the defined scope. GSA P-120 Each owner below uses the word for a different sum on a different base.
- Caltrans, recommended contingency: 30 to 50 percent at project feasibility, 25 at project initiation, 20 at draft project report, 15 at project report, 10 at the preliminary engineer’s estimate and a standard 5 at the final engineer’s estimate. For design estimates the percentage is applied to the subtotal of bid items, supplemental work and Department-furnished materials and expenses. The amounts include known and unidentified risks, and should be exceeded only with a quantified risk register. Caltrans PDPM Chapter 20
- GSA, design contingency for new construction, as a percentage of direct cost: 10 at planning, 7.5 to 10 at concept, 5 to 7.5 at design development, 2 to 5 at 75 percent construction documents, 1 to 3 at 90 percent and 0 at final. Repair and alteration figures are higher from concept design through 90 percent construction documents. A separate construction contingency is 7 percent of the estimated cost at award for new capital construction and 10 percent for the other listed categories. GSA P-120
- FHWA, in guidance dated January 2007 for projects above $500 million: a design contingency around 30 percent may suit the start of final design and should approach 0 at final plans. A construction contingency is normally around 5 to 10 percent, and some projects have used close to 15. FHWA still posted this guidance when we read it, and we found no later edition. FHWA Major Project guidance A newer FHWA page describes a risk review of major projects that models a range of cost outcomes. FHWA CSRA
Our interpretation: each figure is tied to that agency’s milestones, deliverables and cost base. None is a default for a private or municipal landscape project. State the percentage used, what it is a percentage of, what it covers and who chose it.
GSA requires allowances and contingencies to be shown separately and never hidden in unit prices or quantities. It says cost from a scope change must be met by revising the project funding, not from construction contingency. GSA P-120 Caltrans says contingency compensates for limited information and is not a substitute for incomplete design. Caltrans Preparation Guidelines
Caltrans planning estimates also carry separate lines for minor items at 5 to 10 percent of the main items, mobilization usually from 0 to 10 percent of all contract item costs, and supplemental work for work of uncertain amount. Supplemental work is not contingency. Caltrans Preparation Guidelines
Escalation is a separate line. GSA lets the estimator escalate to the midpoint of construction and requires the project’s market study to be a primary source for the escalation allowance. GSA P-120 Caltrans adjusts old bid prices to the present with its price index, then escalates to the expected midpoint of construction using forecast indices. Caltrans Preparation Guidelines FHWA asks that the estimate say how inflation was handled, and suggests national and local references for the rate. FHWA Major Project guidance None of these sources gives a rate we can repeat.
A structure for the estimate
NIST’s 1999 report on UNIFORMAT II says a common elemental classification lets users compare information at every phase. The classification, ASTM E1557-97 in that report, groups site work under element G. G20 Site Improvements holds roadways, parking lots, pedestrian paving, site development and landscaping. The NIST authors also propose a fourth level that the ASTM standard did not have. In that suggested level, G2040 Site Development includes fences and gates, retaining walls, site furnishings, fountains and playing fields. G2050 Landscaping includes fine grading and soil preparation, erosion control measures, topsoil and planting beds, seeding and sodding, planting, planters and irrigation systems. NISTIR 6389 GSA’s policy lists a 2009 edition of E1557. GSA P-120 We did not read a later edition.
Public unit-cost data and its limits
Caltrans Contract Cost Data. The database holds bid item prices from Caltrans contracts for 1993 to 2026. On the day we read it, it reported 3,476,161 records and a latest imported bid opening of November 3, 2026. A search may include all bidders, the awarded bidder only, or the top two to five. Caltrans Contract Cost Data Results give an average, a quantity-weighted average and a standard deviation. An adjusted price scales the original by the general Caltrans Construction Cost Index, not an index for the specific item. Contract Cost Data Help
The site’s own tips, written for Caltrans estimators, say to aim for at least 20 results, limit the search to the project’s district and nearby ones, match the quantity range, and distrust an average when the standard deviation exceeds the minimum or average unit price. Contract Cost Data Search Tips
Caltrans’s guidelines name two pricing methods: previous bid prices, and analysis of production rates, labor costs and material costs. They call previous bid prices the most used and usually most practical method, with conditions. Use similarly sized projects and similar quantities. Adjust for terrain, location, soil, traffic and specifications. The guidelines list what moves a unit price, including small quantities, handwork, difficult access, restricted hours and season. Caltrans Preparation Guidelines WSDOT’s manual warns against taking historical bid data at face value and averaging it. WSDOT M 30-34.04
Our interpretation for landscape work: these are prices bid on state highway contracts, under those specifications and quantities. A planting or irrigation item from that database is a dated reference for similar public roadside work in that district. It is not a current market price for a private garden or a small park, where quantities are smaller and handwork is greater. Quote such a figure with its year, district, quantity and whether it was adjusted.
Private work. We found no public, dated source of unit prices for private landscape work. Commercial cost data products exist; we did not read them. Our interpretation: the method and the record transfer even where the prices do not. Keep bid tabulations from your own projects and written quotes, each with its date, location and quantity, and apply the same tests of sample size and spread.
A national index. FHWA’s National Highway Construction Cost Index tracks highway construction price changes. FHWA NHCCI It measures highway work; we found no public index specific to landscape construction.
A local price list has a purpose. The City of San Diego sets inspection deposits for right-of-way, grading, landscape and irrigation work from a construction cost estimate prepared “using the most current DSD - Unit Price List.” City of San Diego Information Bulletin 502 The department’s engineering forms page says the current Unit Price List is to be used in cost estimates that determine bonding costs. The list it linked on the day we read it is labelled the 2009 Unit Price List, beside a cost estimate template labelled 2023. We opened neither file. City of San Diego, Engineering/Grading Our reading: a list kept for setting bonds and deposits serves that purpose and is not a construction budget.
Change control
Under the federal Changes clause, the contracting officer may change the work by written order within the general scope of the contract. A contractor who treats another instruction as a change must give written notice, and must assert a right to adjustment within 30 days unless the Government extends the period. FAR 52.243-4 An independent government estimate is required for each contract modification expected to exceed the simplified acquisition threshold. FAR 36.203 On federal-aid highway work, major changes need formal approval in advance, and the state must “perform and adequately document a cost analysis” of each negotiated change. Force account procedures are for cases such as a price that cannot be agreed or work of unknown extent. 23 CFR 635.120
Caltrans’s construction manual calls a change order a legally binding document and requires a memorandum with each one. Where appropriate, a change order must state what is to be done, the location and limits, the specification changes, the effect on completion time, and the method and amount of compensation. Once a bid item quantity is known to vary by more than 25 percent from the bid item list, the engineer considers how it will be adjusted. Caltrans Construction Manual, Section 5-3
A change log, as our own method. We suggest one row per change with: a number; the date raised and by whom; what changes and where; the reason, as owner-requested scope change, site condition, design correction or code; drawings and specification sections affected; the cost basis; the amount; the effect on time; who approved and when; and the funding source. Keep two running totals. Changes within the agreed scope are drawn against the contingency. Owner-requested scope changes are totalled separately as a change to the budget, following the GSA rule above. A row moves from proposed to approved only on a signed document. The contract decides who may order a change, how it is priced and how it is funded.
Fees and the designer’s own contract
In California the Landscape Architects Practice Act requires a written contract before work starts, with stated exceptions. It must describe the basis of compensation, including the total price to complete the contract and the method of payment, the procedure for additional services, and the procedure to “accommodate contract changes” in the project, services or compensation. Landscape Architects Practice Act, § 5616 We read the committee’s edition of January 1, 2024; check the current code before relying on it.
On federal architect-engineer contracts for public works or utilities, the contract price for producing and delivering designs, plans, drawings and specifications may not exceed 6 percent of the estimated cost of construction, excluding fees. FAR 15.404-4 How it applies to a contract is for the contracting agency. It is no guide to private fees.
A fee log, as our own method. For each phase in the contract: the agreed fee; hours and labor cost to date; our estimate of the percentage of work complete and the fee earned at that percentage; the amount invoiced; subconsultant fees and reimbursable expenses as separate lines; and each additional service with the date requested and the date the client approved it in writing. We suggest entering an additional service when it is requested and billing it only after it is approved. § 5616 requires the contract to describe a procedure for additional services and for contract changes. It does not say what the procedure must be.
What we could not settle
- What AACE’s road and rail matrix gives as accuracy ranges, and whether any AACE practice addresses landscape or planting work. The full documents are sold. We read free previews of the August 7, 2020 revisions and did not confirm they are current.
- On what basis WSDOT states its ranges.
- How well any published range holds for landscape contracts. We found no primary study of landscape bids against estimates.
- A public, dated source of unit prices for private or small-scale landscape work. Commercial cost data products were not read.
- Whether the 2023 cost estimate template on the City of San Diego forms page carries prices later than the 2009 list.
- Where landscape work sits in MasterFormat, which GSA uses for later estimates. It is licensed and we did not read it.
- What standard private contract forms require for change orders. They are licensed and we did not read them.
Using this in Field Method
Material Studio reads quantities from a model’s geometry and builds a priced schedule. Its page describes the result as a design-stage material estimate and says it is neither a contractor bid nor a cost plan. Its sample rates are placeholders. Enter rates you have sourced and dated, and record what the total leaves out. An estimate class belongs to a full construction estimate, so do not put one on a material schedule.
Sources
- AACE International — Recommended Practice 17R-97: Cost Estimate Classification System (preview, rev. August 7, 2020)
- AACE International — Recommended Practice 56R-08: Cost Estimate Classification System, Building and General Construction Industries (preview, rev. August 7, 2020)
- AACE International — Recommended Practice 98R-18: Cost Estimate Classification System, Road and Rail Transportation Infrastructure Industries (preview, rev. August 7, 2020)
- US General Services Administration — PBS 1000.6B, P-120 Public Buildings Service Cost and Schedule Management Policy Requirements (November 7, 2022)
- Washington State Department of Transportation — Cost Estimating Manual for Projects, M 30-34.04 (February 2026)
- Caltrans — Project Development Procedures Manual, Chapter 20: Project Capital Cost Estimates (February 29, 2024)
- Federal Highway Administration — Major Project Program Cost Estimating Guidance (January 2007)
- Federal Highway Administration — Major Projects, Cost Estimating: CSRA
- Caltrans — Preparation Guidelines for Project Capital Cost Estimates (May 6, 2024)
- NIST — NISTIR 6389, UNIFORMAT II Elemental Classification for Building Specifications, Cost Estimating, and Cost Analysis (October 1999)
- Caltrans — Contract Cost Data
- Caltrans — Contract Cost Data: Help
- Caltrans — Contract Cost Data: Search Tips
- Federal Highway Administration — National Highway Construction Cost Index (NHCCI)
- City of San Diego Development Services — Information Bulletin 502: Fee Schedule for Grading/Public Right-of-Way Permits and Mapping Actions (July 2026)
- City of San Diego Development Services — Engineering/Grading forms and publications
- Federal Acquisition Regulation — 52.243-4 Changes
- Federal Acquisition Regulation — 36.203 Government estimate of construction costs
- 23 CFR 635.120 — Changes and extra work
- Caltrans — Construction Manual, Chapter 5, Section 3: Change Orders (July 2025)
- California Architects Board, Landscape Architects Technical Committee — Landscape Architects Practice Act (January 1, 2024)
- Federal Acquisition Regulation — 15.404-4 Profit
Try a relevant tool
These tools support site review and design studies. Read each tool’s stated capabilities and limits before use.
Explore Material Studio