A headset is meant to put a reviewer inside a design at eye level, with the model shown at one to one. Whether that leads to better understanding or better decisions is a question for experiments. The controlled studies we could read are small and their results are mixed. In a headset, people sized some spaces and stated preferences differently than on a desktop screen or from pictures. In the one public meeting study, which used a room of screens and no headsets, the immersive format drew more comments and more recall. The one study that tested spatial learning found the desktop did as well or better. Two studies recorded discomfort, and both found some in the immersive condition. The makers of the common tools document how to open a model in a headset. None of the pages we read gives evidence that doing so improves a review.
We read each source on November 14, 2026.
What the comparison studies measured
“VR” covers several setups in this literature. A head-mounted display, or HMD, is a headset. Desktop VR is a navigable 3D model on a monitor. A CAVE is a room of large screens. Results for one do not transfer to another without care.
Designing in a headset versus on a desktop. Azarby and Rice gave 60 design students and professionals, in architecture, landscape architecture, industrial design and graphic design, the same task in two systems: SketchUp on a desktop, and the VR Sketch program with a headset and hand controllers. Each participant resized corridors and enclosures to fit written guidelines, such as a space for a stated number of people, in both systems. Half began in each system. With plain surfaces, corridor widths and enclosure areas did not differ significantly between systems (p = 0.83 and 0.13). With a brick pattern they did (p = 0.003 for both). Texture changed the sizes people chose on the desktop and did not in the headset. Of the participants, 93 percent rated the eye-level view very helpful and 82 percent rated full immersion very helpful. Azarby and Rice 2022
The study shows that the display changed design decisions. It does not show which set of sizes was more correct, because nothing was built.
Planting design by students. We read only the abstract of this study. George, Fernandez and Summerlin had students at three universities complete a planting design exercise by hand drafting and in VR. Students used more trees and a larger portion of the site in VR. The authors say this may indicate improved spatial understanding. The abstract does not give the number of students, the VR system used, or whether the differences were tested statistically. More trees and more of the site used is a change in the design. We cannot tell from the abstract whether it is a better one. George, Fernandez and Summerlin 2022
Learning a layout. Srivastava and colleagues assigned 40 university students, 27 of them male, to a desktop or to an Oculus Rift CV1, with the same hand controller for movement and no walking in the headset. Participants explored an outdoor virtual environment of 1,500 by 2,000 metres and then drew a sketch map. The desktop group reported less motion sickness and less task effort, and the authors describe both as very low overall. The desktop group recalled junctions, and the order of streets and objects around a junction, better. Street segments did not differ. Object associations favoured the desktop in the first analysis and did not differ significantly after the data were transformed. Sense of presence did not differ between groups. The authors note a confound: the desktop group chose to explore for longer. Srivastava et al. 2019
That study removed walking from the headset condition on purpose. Our reading is that it describes a seated or standing review with a controller, which is how many office reviews are run, and says nothing about room-scale walking.
Stated preferences for a street. We read only the abstract of this study too. Zhu, Guo and Zhao ran a stated choice experiment on a real street renewal project with 48 university students from non-design majors, comparing a headset with pictures of rendered 3D scenes. The abstract reports significant quantitative but limited qualitative differences in aggregate preferences, and that some features that were unappealing in pictures were more favoured in VR. Individual decision patterns became more alike in VR, and effects were stronger for female participants. Zhu, Guo and Zhao 2021
What happened in a public meeting format
Meenar and Kitson recruited 40 participants into four focus groups of ten in Glassboro, New Jersey, to review a planning scenario for three downtown blocks. One group saw a 2D video of the 3D model with an oral presentation. One saw an immersive simulation with a recorded narration. One saw it with added ambient sound and scent. A fourth saw the video and then, in a second session, the simulation with added sound and scent. The immersive sessions took place in a university CAVE lab, with a curved wall of eight adjoining screens 7 feet high and 40 feet wide. They were not viewed on headsets, and the simulations were pre-recorded. Meenar and Kitson 2020
The counts they report:
- Comments. 17 after the video, 63 after the immersive simulation and 77 with added sound and scent.
- Recall. Design elements recalled on hand-drawn mental maps rose by 50 percent from the video group to the immersive group, and by 30 percent to the group with added sound and scent. The authors attribute the lower second figure to that group’s lower familiarity with the area.
- Emotional responses. 47 after the video and 75 after the immersive simulation. The authors found that 27 percent of emotional responses concerned the technology and not the design.
- Negative comments. In the group that saw both formats, negative comments rose from 17 to 33. Of the 33, 24 concerned the design and nine concerned the technology. The authors link part of the rise to motion sickness, dizziness or disorientation, which a few participants in each immersive group noted.
These are counts from four groups of ten, analysed with content analysis and descriptive statistics. The groups differed in familiarity with the site, and the authors say so. They also list as weaknesses the time, budget and access to a facility that the method needs, and they report that questions about the technology do not mean engagement with the design. Meenar and Kitson 2020
Our interpretation: the study supports the claim that an immersive format gets people talking and remembering. It does not show that the feedback was better for the design, and it warns that part of the reaction is to the medium.
Headsets as a measuring instrument
Two further studies use a headset to collect judgments, with no screen condition to compare against.
Kim and Kim built eight enclosed squares with ratios of width to surrounding building height from 1/3 to 6/1 and had 69 urban planning students rate them in an Oculus Rift. The preferred ratios for most qualities were around four to six, where the design theorists they cite mostly propose values below three. The authors list limits, including a single size of square and a homogeneous group of students. Kim and Kim 2019
Our reading: with no screen condition and no real square, the study cannot separate what people prefer from how the headset shows size. We would not take the ratios as design values.
Tabrizian and colleagues showed 100 undergraduates 24 photographic panoramas of a city park in an Oculus CV1 headset, 25 seconds each before a rating, in sessions averaging 40 minutes. Each participant rated one of three qualities. Ratings of visual access, naturalness and complexity were predicted from lidar-based viewscape metrics with adjusted R² of 0.65, 0.62 and 0.42. The authors note that photograph-based scenes are static, limit movement, and include content such as people and cars that the spatial data do not hold. Tabrizian et al. 2020
For practice, the second study is a reminder that a 360-degree photograph of the existing site in a headset is a different thing from a navigable model of a proposal. Both are called VR.
Sickness, as the studies report it
Saredakis and colleagues pooled 55 studies of head-mounted displays with 3,016 participants. The measure was the Simulator Sickness Questionnaire, or SSQ. Saredakis et al. 2020
- Overall level. The pooled total score was 28.00 (95% CI 24.66 to 31.35). The authors compare this with categories from earlier work on military flight simulators, in which scores of 10 to 15 indicate significant symptoms and scores over 20 indicate a problem simulator. They caution that those cut-offs may not apply to the general population.
- Content. Pooled totals were 34.26 for gaming, 27.42 for 360-degree video, 21.71 for minimalist content and 17.33 for scenic content. The authors note that dropout rates did not always follow the scores.
- Movement. Pooled totals were 32.55 for movement by controller, a category that included flying, controller walking, teleporting and driving, 28.04 when stationary and 16.99 for walking. On the nausea and oculomotor subscales the stationary category scored highest. The review gives no separate result for teleporting.
- Time. Studies were grouped as under 10 minutes, 10 minutes or more, and 20 minutes or more. Total scores did not differ significantly between the groups (p = 0.066). Nausea and disorientation scores were lower under 10 minutes than at 10 minutes or more. They were also lower at 20 minutes or more than at 10 minutes or more, the group with the most gaming content.
- Dropouts. Across 46 experiments that reported them, a mean of 15.6 percent of participants stopped because of sickness. The authors note that 22 studies did not report dropouts, and that the figure may be inflated if many of those had none.
- Who. The review found no sex difference. Samples with a mean age of 35 or more scored lower, on a small evidence base. The pooled mean age was 24.
Heterogeneity was high throughout, and the studies are mostly of young adults. The literature search was run in October 2018. The authors say 35 percent of the included papers used older headsets, which makes it difficult to predict symptoms with current ones. Saredakis et al. 2020
A public meeting has an older and more varied audience, which these data describe poorly.
Two of the studies above report discomfort. Srivastava and colleagues measured higher sickness ratings in the headset group, at a level they call very low overall. Srivastava et al. 2019 Meenar and Kitson heard of it from a few participants in each immersive group. Meenar and Kitson 2020 The other studies we read in full do not report on it. This is a summary of research and is not health advice. Follow the headset maker’s own guidance for users.
What the tool makers document
Each paragraph below reports the maker’s documentation on the date we read it. Check the page for your version before a review.
Twinmotion. Epic’s documentation describes VR in three places: panorama sets on Twinmotion Cloud, local presentations, and Twinmotion in Editor or Presenter mode. It lists headsets with a column for whether each was tested. On our reading date HP Reverb G2, HTC VIVE Pro 2, Meta Quest 2 and 3 and Varjo models were marked tested, and HTC VIVE, Oculus Rift and Valve Index were marked not tested. In VR mode, users choose options from a VR menu and move through the scene by teleporting. The page says hotspots in cloud panorama sets let viewers teleport, which it describes as minimizing the risk of motion sickness. The page does not state a Twinmotion version. Twinmotion, Viewing Content in Virtual Reality The specifications page lists VR mode as not suitable for its minimum requirements and suitable for its high-end ones, which call for a graphics card with at least 12 GB of dedicated memory and 64 GB or more of system memory on Windows. Twinmotion, Hardware and Software Specifications
Enscape (headset list only). A Chaos help article, marked as updated four months before we read it, says Enscape officially supports the Meta Quest 3 and the HTC Vive Pro 2. The article does not state an Enscape version. We could not open the linked knowledge base page on setup and requirements. Chaos Help Center
Unreal Engine. The documentation for version 5.9 describes a VR Template as a starting point. It uses the OpenXR framework, which the page calls the multi-company standard for VR and AR development. It includes teleport movement and snap turning, and a navigation mesh that limits where a user may teleport. Its Spectator Screen Mode lets others view the experience while one person wears the headset, and the page says it is not compatible with mobile VR devices such as the Quest. Unreal Engine 5.9, VR Template
Blender. The manual for version 5.3 describes a VR Scene Inspection add-on that shares the 3D viewport with a headset through OpenXR. It states that the feature set is limited to scene inspection. Blender 5.3 Manual, VR Scene Inspection The manual’s hardware page describes OpenXR support as still limited and gives a table of OpenXR platforms by operating system. Blender 5.3 Manual, Head-Mounted Displays Both links follow the latest manual and will move to later versions.
SketchUp. Trimble’s help pages record that the earlier viewers have ended. SketchUp Viewer for Virtual Reality stopped being offered on July 8, 2024 and lost support after July 8, 2025. SketchUp Help, End of Support The Viewer for Meta Quest page says the app is no longer available to download from September 16, 2025. SketchUp Help, Viewer for Meta Quest Of the two alternatives the End of Support page names, that leaves the Trimble Connect Visualizer. Its VR Mode uses the OpenVR interface and needs a compatible device with Steam and SteamVR. The page does not state a version. SketchUp Help, Trimble Connect Visualizer
The SketchUp record is the plainest case for writing down the software, version and date of any VR review. A viewer used on one project may not exist for the next.
A short protocol for a review, as our own suggestion
This list is our interpretation of the sources above. It has not been tested.
- State the question. No study we read shows that judgments made in a headset are more accurate than on a screen, and the one test of layout learning favoured the desktop. Say in advance what the session is meant to answer.
- Keep a screen in the room. Show the same model on a monitor, by a spectator view or a second session, so those who decline the headset still take part.
- Decide how people will move and for how long, and write it down. The pooled review did not test teleporting on its own, and total scores did not differ significantly by duration. Epic’s Twinmotion page describes teleport hotspots as minimizing the risk of motion sickness. That is the maker’s statement, and we read no study that tests it. For limits on use, follow the headset maker’s guidance.
- Tell people they can stop. Record who stopped and why.
- Separate comments on the medium from comments on the design. In the Glassboro study, 27 percent of emotional responses were about the technology.
- Record the setup. Software and version, headset, how movement worked, eye height, and what in the model was placeholder.
What we could not settle
- Whether headset review improves built outcomes or reduces changes during construction. We found no primary study that follows a landscape project that far.
- Effect sizes for landscape architecture specifically. The one landscape design study we found was read as an abstract without a sample size.
- Whether people judge sizes and distances in a headset as they do on site. We read no study that compares headset judgments with a built space.
- How sickness in current standalone headsets compares with the older devices in the pooled studies, and whether teleporting causes less of it than other controller movement.
- How older adults and people with vestibular or visual conditions fare in a public session.
- The current Enscape setup requirements, and what the Twinmotion headset list is for a named version.
- A participation study with more than a few dozen people that we could open and read in full.
Field Method tools
Field Method has no VR tool. Photo tools makes cameras for Blender from site photographs, which the Landscape Camera Setup add-on reads. Neither page mentions VR, and the add-on’s page says it has not yet been run inside Blender.
Sources
- Azarby and Rice (2022) — Understanding the Effects of Virtual Reality System Usage on Spatial Perception: The Potential Impacts of Immersive Virtual Reality on Spatial Design Decisions, Sustainability 14(16), 10326
- George, Fernandez and Summerlin (2022) — The Impact of Virtual Reality on Student Design Decisions, Landscape Journal 41(1), 31–44
- Srivastava, Rimzhim, Vijay, Singh and Chandra (2019) — Desktop VR Is Better Than Non-ambulatory HMD VR for Spatial Learning, Frontiers in Robotics and AI
- Zhu, Guo and Zhao (2021) — Planning participants' preferential differences under immersive virtual reality and conventional representations, Environment and Planning B 48(7)
- Meenar and Kitson (2020) — Using Multi-Sensory and Multi-Dimensional Immersive Virtual Reality in Participatory Planning, Urban Science 4(3), 34
- Kim and Kim (2019) — Finding the Optimal D/H Ratio for an Enclosed Urban Square, International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health 16(5), 865
- Tabrizian and colleagues (2020) — High Resolution Viewscape Modeling Evaluated Through Immersive Virtual Environments, ISPRS International Journal of Geo-Information 9(7), 445
- Saredakis and colleagues (2020) — Factors Associated With Virtual Reality Sickness in Head-Mounted Displays: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis, Frontiers in Human Neuroscience 14, 96
- Epic Games — Twinmotion Documentation: Viewing Content in Virtual Reality
- Epic Games — Twinmotion Documentation: Hardware and Software Specifications
- Chaos — Help Center: Which Virtual Reality headsets are supported? (Enscape)
- Epic Games — Unreal Engine 5.9 Documentation: VR Template
- Blender Foundation — Blender 5.3 Manual: VR Scene Inspection
- Blender Foundation — Blender 5.3 Manual: Configuring Peripherals, Head-Mounted Displays
- Trimble — SketchUp Help: End of Support, SketchUp Viewers for Hololens and Virtual Reality
- Trimble — SketchUp Help: Viewer for Meta Quest
- Trimble — SketchUp Help: Using Trimble Connect Visualizer
Try a relevant tool
These tools support site review and design studies. Read each tool’s stated capabilities and limits before use.
Explore Photo tools