A quality review asks whether a set of drawings is complete, coordinated and consistent with its requirements. A risk register asks what could still go wrong and who is watching it. Public agencies do both in writing, and they publish enough of it to copy the structure.
This article reports what we could read from agency and standards-body sources on November 14, 2026, then proposes a small issue log and risk register built from it. The proposal is our method. No agency requires it, and it is not legal, engineering or professional-liability advice. The main finding is that the agencies we read review at fixed milestones and against written lists. Some name the reviewing role, and some ask for earlier comments to be answered before the next review.
What agencies publish about review timing
GSA. GSA’s standards page now leads with the PBS Core Building Standards (CBS) and describes the 2024 P100 facilities standards in the past tense. GSA, Core Building Standards A memorandum dated September 21, 2026 issues the 2026 CBS for PBS projects awarded on or after October 1, 2026, and names a CBS submittal matrix as a supporting resource. GSA 2026 CBS Memorandum The matrix GSA links today is titled for the 2025 Interim CBS and marked Version 1.0. We found no matrix dated 2026, so we use that one and do not cite the older P100 matrix.
The matrix organizes deliverables by phase: preliminary concept, concept development and final concept, then design development at 100% and construction documents at 65%, 95% and final. It also sorts them by delivery method and discipline. It says it records baseline submittal requirements, that a contract may add more, and that project teams must still provide the standard of care for a fully constructible set. GSA CBS Submittal Matrix Our reading is that a client’s checklist sets a floor, and the designer’s own review still has to happen.
Caltrans, landscape specifically. A 2021 planting policy memorandum lists the milestones at which the District Landscape Architect and the District Maintenance Representative review landscape design and implementation: project initiation, project approval and environmental document, 35% conceptual design, 60% design, 95% plans, specifications and estimate, and ready-to-list. It adds construction review and walk-throughs at irrigation layout and before plant establishment, and a final plant establishment walk-through before contract acceptance. The memorandum says it will expire when the maximum-cost policy for planting and water assessment in Chapter 29 of the Project Development Procedures Manual has been updated. Caltrans Planting Policy On November 14, 2026 the Caltrans manual page listed Chapter 29, Landscape Architecture, as last updated on 5/24/2018, which is before the memorandum. Caltrans PDPM We did not check whether Caltrans has replaced the policy by another route, so confirm its status with the district.
County and City of San Diego. The County’s landscape documentation package checklist sets turnaround and a limit on rounds: 30 days for the first plan check, one week for the second and third, and a new fee and application if plans are still unacceptable after the third. County of San Diego PDS-404e The City’s Landscape section reviews building, grading and public improvement plans against the Land Development Manual landscape standards, the landscape regulations and conditions of earlier approvals. City of San Diego, Landscape Plan Review These are permit reviews, separate from design QC. They show how many cycles an agency expects.
What agency checklists ask for
Scope and commitments. The Caltrans local assistance PS&E checklist is completed by the local agency. It asks the agency to confirm that the PS&E matches the scope in a scoping document or application, or that approvals exist for later changes. It also asks whether the PS&E responds to the environmental document, permit conditions and other agreements, and includes the environmental commitment record. The form states that Caltrans has not conducted a comprehensive review of the package. Caltrans LAPM Exhibit 12-D The instructions state that failing to check the environmental box results in denial of the request for authorization. Caltrans LAPM Exhibit 12-E The checklist covers local agency projects with federal funds. The idea we take from it is a scope check and a commitments check at every phase.
Drawing set contents. The same checklist lists an erosion control plan if required and ADA compliance where applicable, and asks for current standard plans and specifications by year or version. Caltrans LAPM Exhibit 12-D The City’s development permit requirements say the architectural site plan, grading plan, topographic map and landscape plans shall be prepared on the same scale. They also ask a landscape plan to show all required street trees and proposed utilities in the public right-of-way, and a legend with botanical and common names, quantities, container-size percentages, mature height and spread, and the form and function of each plant symbol. City of San Diego Land Development Manual, Section 4
Plan content and consistency. The County checklist asks that the landscape plan show retained and removed plants with location, botanical and common name, size and quantity, and that the plant legend give each species’ plant factor from WUCOLS. It asks for soil amendment and planting specifications, mulch depth, and root barriers for trees within 5 feet of hardscape. County of San Diego PDS-404e Requirements in other jurisdictions may differ.
Irrigation and water. The same County list asks for hydrozones identified by water use class, point of connection and backflow device, valve and sprinkler data in a legend, pipe sizing including sleeves, design and static pressure with a recording date, and an automatic controller that is weather-based or has a moisture sensor, with a rain sensor. Its worksheet check confirms that estimated total water use does not exceed the maximum applied water allowance and that average irrigation efficiency meets or exceeds 0.75. County of San Diego PDS-404e The checklist asks that worksheet entries conform to the plans. That is a cross-document consistency check.
Grading and drainage. The County grading plan items include finished elevations of each landscaped area, slope heights, drainage patterns, pad and finish grades, and vegetated stormwater BMPs shown and labeled. County of San Diego PDS-404e
Coordination and QC. GSA’s matrix names QC items directly. Its final concept pages list a QC review to verify that the final concept can be constructed within the project budget. They also list, under site and landscape strategy, that all second peer review commentary has been responded to. Its 65% construction documents pages list a BIM QC checklist and a 3D design coordination report, and its 95% pages list both again. Under site and landscape strategy at 65%, the matrix lists site plans covering hardscape, layout, grading, planting, soils, lighting and irrigation if applicable, then sections and elevations, details, schedules for pavement, planting, furnishings and lighting, and specifications as required. GSA CBS Submittal Matrix We could not confirm how GSA applies these to a small landscape package.
Signatures and responsibility. A 2022 Caltrans memorandum, addressed to its deputy directors, division chiefs and district directors, covers PS&E packages. It says the title sheet carries the seal and signature of the lowest-classification licensed professional delegated general responsibility for coordinating a complete PS&E package, and that a licensed landscape architect may be tasked with that coordination depending on scope. It also says individual plan sheets are to be signed by the licensed professional who has the technical expertise and is responsible for the content of that sheet. Only one license number, seal and signature goes on a plan. Printed names and signatures of others directly involved in developing and reviewing the plan may be added without a license number, seal or professional designation, along the left margin of each sheet except on structure plans. Caltrans Seal and Signature Memo That is Caltrans policy for its own projects. In California, the Landscape Architects Technical Committee sets licensure standards and enforces the laws and regulations that govern the practice of landscape architecture. California LATC Take questions about your own seal and signature duties to your licensing board.
Standards for drawing consistency
The United States National CAD Standard, Version 7 (2024), published by the National Institute of Building Sciences, combines the AIA CAD Layer Guidelines, the CSI Uniform Drawing System (Modules 1 to 8) and the NIBS BIM Implementation and Plotting Guidelines. NIBS, United States National CAD Standard The standard is licensed, and we did not read its text. Our view is that a shared sheet and layer convention gives reviewers something to check against.
A review plan by phase (our method)
The structure below is ours. It puts the published checks into common design phases. Adjust it to your contract, your jurisdiction and your size.
Schematic design. Check the program and scope against the client’s brief and any scoping document. List known commitments: environmental conditions, easements, design guidelines and agency standards. Confirm that the base information is current and that its source and date are recorded. Review budget against the concept, as the GSA matrix does at final concept. Reviewer: a principal or senior person who did not draw the concept.
Design development. Check scale and coordination between landscape, grading and architectural plans, as the City requires. Check that every plant and material in the legend appears on a plan and that quantities and sizes agree. Check irrigation concepts against the water budget approach your jurisdiction uses. Check proposed utilities in the right-of-way against street tree locations. Run a peer review with a second licensed professional where scope allows, and record each comment and response.
Construction documents. Do an internal QC pass before every submission, including the early ones. At the first stage, such as 65%, check that schedules are complete and enlargement plans exist. At 95%, check specifications against drawings, check the worksheet or calculations against the plans, and check that standard details and specifications are the current year or version, as the Caltrans checklist asks. Our article on tracking regulatory updates in landscape practice covers where editions are published. Before issue, confirm that the agency submittal checklist is complete, that sheets carry the signatures and dates the agency requires, and that the permit conditions are reflected in the set.
Bidding and construction. During bidding, we suggest logging each addendum item in the issue log. The Caltrans planting memo shows landscape reviews at irrigation layout, before plant establishment and at the final walk-through. We use those as review points.
Two rules keep the plan simple. Each review has a named reviewer who is not the author. No phase closes while a comment is open, except one marked deferred with a reason and an owner. Both rules are ours. No source states them.
A one-person practice cannot meet the first rule alone. Our suggestion is an outside licensed professional under a reciprocal review arrangement. Failing that, do a self-check on a different day against the written list, and record it in the log as a self-check.
An issue log (our method)
Keep one table per project. One row per comment. Suggested columns:
- ID and date raised
- Phase and review type (self-check, peer review, coordination, agency)
- Sheet or specification section
- Comment, in one sentence
- Category: scope, coordination, quantity, code or agency requirement, graphics, specification
- Severity: must fix before issue, should fix, note
- Owner and due date
- Response and date
- Verified by someone other than the owner, and date
- Status: open, answered, verified, deferred
We think the verification column matters most. In our method, a response that says “revised” stays open until a second person confirms the change on the sheet. One agency checklist ties a resubmittal to its comments. At the second plan check, the County says plans will not be reviewed without the plan check letter. County of San Diego PDS-404e We suggest keeping comments and responses together in the same way.
A risk register (our method)
Caltrans defines a risk as an uncertain event or condition that, if it occurs, has a negative or positive effect on cost, schedule, scope or quality. Its directive sets minimum risk management requirements by a scalability level based on project capital cost. Minor B projects are left to the district’s discretion, and levels 1 to 3 call for a risk register. At level 1 the register uses qualitative analysis, and risks with medium or high probability get a quantitative analysis. The register is to be updated and managed through the project life cycle, and every risk is to be retired before final project closeout. Caltrans PDD-09R2 The directive was effective July 1, 2024 and shows a review-by date of July 1, 2026. On November 14, 2026 the Caltrans directives page still listed PDD-09R2. Caltrans PD Directives
We think a qualitative register is enough for most landscape work. Suggested columns:
- ID, date opened, phase
- Risk, written as cause, event and effect: “Utility locations in the right-of-way are unconfirmed, so street trees may need to move, delaying the permit set”
- Likelihood and impact: low, medium or high, with your own written meaning for each
- Owner
- Response: avoid, reduce, transfer, accept, or exploit an opportunity
- Trigger: what you would see if it were happening
- Status and next review date
Minnesota DOT’s guidance on risk checklists adds a caution. A checklist of common risks should be used only after the team has identified risks on its own, because a checklist may not contain important project-specific risks. Minnesota DOT, Risk Checklists The document carries no date, and its file properties show 2008, so treat it as older guidance. Its example is a sample risk list from a 2007 Caltrans handbook. We did not read that handbook, so we do not use the list here.
Caltrans also ties risk reviews to milestones. Its directive requires certification of the register before approval of the project initiation document, before the project report and environmental document, and before ready to list. Caltrans PDD-09R2 We suggest reviewing the register at the same moments as the QC reviews above: end of schematic, end of design development, each construction documents issue, and before bidding. The pairing is our idea.
How the two logs connect. In our method, a repeated finding in the issue log is evidence for a risk. If three reviews in a row find unreconciled quantities between plant legend and schedule, add a risk and an owner. The reverse also holds. A risk with a trigger should name the review where the trigger will be checked.
Limits of this method
- Agency reviews check compliance with that agency’s rules. A passed plan check does not show that a set is coordinated.
- The lists above are for specific programs. Highway PS&E, a federal building and a county landscape ordinance do not share requirements.
- The issue log and register do not replace the contract terms, licensing rules or insurance advice that apply to your firm.
- We did not test either log on a live project. Time cost and effectiveness are unknown.
What we could not settle
- Will GSA issue a submittal matrix dated for the 2026 CBS? The one it links today is titled for the 2025 Interim CBS.
- What do ASLA, CLARB, state licensing boards or professional liability insurers publish on practice QC for landscape architects? We found nothing dated that we could rely on.
- ISO 31000 could not be read, so we do not describe its process. The PMI standards are not public.
- The USACE quality management regulation and the Florida DOT plans preparation manual chapter on quality control could not be confirmed as current editions, so we left them out.
- Has Caltrans replaced the 2021 planting policy by another memorandum? Chapter 29 itself has not changed since 2018.
- The current Caltrans risk handbook appears to be available to staff only. What scales, sample risks and response definitions does it set?
- We did not trace the County’s water worksheet checks to the state model ordinance or its current edition.
- How many comments per review and how long a review takes in landscape practice? We found no published data.
Using this in Field Method
In Site Lens, Construction Documents lists every sheet of the tool’s drawing set by number and title. Drawing Set takes an issue, revision, preparer and reviewer record. The tool page says these fields document your entries and do not certify review or approval. Its Code Compliance Toolbox review record tracks evidence, unresolved issues and required professional review, and makes no compliance determination. The tool page describes no review comment log and no risk register. Keep the project issue log and register in a spreadsheet or a project management system you already use.
Sources
- GSA — Core Building Standards for the Public Buildings Service
- GSA — 2026 PBS Core Building Standards Memorandum (September 21, 2026)
- GSA — 2025 Interim Core Building Standards (CBS) Submittal Matrix, Version 1.0
- Caltrans — Planting Policy memorandum (June 1, 2021)
- Caltrans — Project Development Procedures Manual (PDPM)
- County of San Diego — Landscape Documentation Package Checklist, PDS-404e (Rev. 09/21/2026)
- City of San Diego — Landscape Plan Review
- Caltrans — Local Assistance Procedures Manual, Exhibit 12-D: PS&E Checklist
- Caltrans — Local Assistance Procedures Manual, Exhibit 12-E: PS&E Checklist Instructions
- City of San Diego — Land Development Manual, Volume I, Chapter 1, Section 4: Development Permits/Approvals (October 2024)
- Caltrans — Seal, Signature, and Roles and Responsibilities of Registered/Licensed Professionals on Project Plans, Specifications, and Reports (April 12, 2022)
- California Landscape Architects Technical Committee
- NIBS — United States National CAD Standard (NCS)
- Caltrans — Project Delivery Directive PDD-09R2, Program and Project Risk Management
- Caltrans — Project Delivery (PD) Directives
- Minnesota DOT — Risk Checklists (Cost Estimating guidance)
Try a relevant tool
These tools support site review and design studies. Read each tool’s stated capabilities and limits before use.
Explore Site Lens: 3D site analysis and trees